Sylvia or Harvey

[bjrouse]

Which one.
I have Sylvia but I am looking to lower my "outs" for byes in rd's 5 & 16.

[tferrier18]

Harvey for sure

[Prospector_1]

It's a tough one, isn't it. Harvey is at an age where things can go down hill very quickly. Sylvia is up and down, and seems to get injured. 6 of one, half a dozen of the other. Harvey by a whisker for me - if he survives he should be great, but age is certainly a risk here.

Besides, everybody loves to watch him play, and if he dies, well, you just buy the best premium mid or forward you can manage - with Sylvia, you're gonna wonder when's it gonna happen, and how long 'til he's back.

[tferrier18]

Harvey's always been so fit though, he hasn't shown a single sign of ageing or slowing down...we all saw his point of the year against west coast..

I reckon he's got a full season in him for sure

[bjrouse]

I am leaning towards Harvey for both the byes aspect and also Nth are on the improve. Not saying his stats will improve a great deal but it should make it easier for him to maintain them