My Team 2011 plz rate

[maddhawker]

Hey peeps I'm back in 2011 :) woohoo bring it on!!!!! Please rate and critise this crap outta me if needed. All your feedback is much appreciated ay

Backs:
Goddard, Gibbs, broughton, mackie, grimes, otten, heppel
(pupoluo, duigan, Toy)


Mids:
Swanny, Montagna, Anthony, Swallow, Gaff, Savage
(hibberd, hine, shnieder)

Ruck:
Sandilands, Cox ( Z Clarke, J redden)

Forwards:
Chapman, franklin, goodes, riewoldt, knights, krakour,
(matera, mzunga, lisle)

Please rate and give feedback

[BGK]

I dont like Mackie. IMO you could bring in Adcock. I read somewhere that he is finally uninjured and with a bit of luck could be in for a big year. At the very least he should make you some cash.

I don't know why but i really don't like Anthony. Its probably just me but i would try to upgrade him to an outright gun.

I have no real info on Savage but he looks a little strange there as do your 3 bench options but they will probably change a million times before the season starts.

Rucks are good. Redden is my only question mark but i don't have another certain starter option. I'm looking at Derickxz. No real reason but he looked pretty good on the weekend.

I think Goodes is a risk. He is pretty old and he burnt me a little last year. If he is playing forward i would find another option.

If you can afford to i think Prestia will be better than Matera but wait and see how they go in the NAB cup.

Hope this helps

[n4cr123]

no room for petrie anywhere?/

[maddhawker]

Hey guys cheers for that yeah my bench miss and savage are def gunna change a million times lol I am quite unsure about Petrie... And goodes I wanted as a bit of unique as noone will have him lol but if he is up forward I will be giving him the boot and maybe getting Brennan. I am also unsure about Anthony and would love to trade him for maybe cross/ selwood/ hodge?? Is there any better bench mids u could suggest? Thanks again your feedback always helps alot and is there any chance mackie will be playing mid a bit more now
Gazza is gone??