gilbert or Fisher

[jmcphe]

 gilbert or Fisher
over to you...

[Alex7089]

Gilbert for me. The role change should do well for him, I can see him improving where as Fisher will probably stagnate/slide.

[steven_ora]

take the rapist imo

[pyronerd]

Gilbert for me. The role change should do well for him, I can see him improving where as Fisher will probably stagnate/slide.

+1 gilbert can score points both back and forward, fisher will stay around the same IMO

[pyronerd]

take the rapist imo

not a rapist, a pornographic photographer :P

[tferrier18]

Very hard to separate the two but I prefer Fisher mainly because Gilbert shanks the ball very often which is -8 points...he makes up for it by taking a showereload of marks from oppositions but will he get that many marks this year if he goes forward?

Also Fisher's two GF performances have swayed me towards him. You can always judge a player by their performance in a final series

[Alex7089]

He will kick goals and take contested marks if he goes forward.

[diddley]

i see gilbert getting more scoring opportunities up forward. did his job well done back, but SC wise, i think he will rise in stats this year. whereas fisher i dont think will change much at all, if not go down a smidge.

[tferrier18]

will he kick goals? he's not the best forward...

[Cruiseon]

Difficult to seperare the two? Presume you don't mean rapists & pornographic photographers!

They've got a lot if things covered at St.Kilda but I'd prefer Gilbert.

[McRooster]

MPP for Gilbert holds sway  ;)

Stay premium

[freezer]

Rapist at St.Kilda? Are we talking Milne, Montagna? How far back can we go?

[McRooster]

freezer, just pump the brakes a little mate and keep it premium  ;)

[dylsta05]

yeah gilbert for me, reason he will ave more