colin sylvia

[steven_ora]

am i the only one who doesnt rate this guy? nearly every team has him am i crazy for having goodes instead of sylvia? lets face it goodes is a proven peformer for many years where as sylvia has only averaged 90+ once in his career. Also sylvia has only played 18 games at best so hes never played a full season. i also think he had a very good season last year and only averaged 88? so can someone tell me why he is so popular this year and also is goodes or anyone else around that price range a better option???

[ando_10]

your right your better off going with goodes
sylvia to inconsistent

[rollsroyce]

I agree. To inconsistent plus he has not played a full year ever.

People have not thought much. Who is Melbourne's best player. Sylvia. Who do you think club will tag Sylvia. Prefer not to take the risk early on and maybe upgrade if he proves himself this year. Dont mind paying a premium if he is worth it

[steven_ora]

exactly.. so is goodes worth it you think? i no he has a history of slow starts but in the end does that really mean anything? this year i have heard talks of him playing back in the midfield and rests up forward which i am excited about!

[ando_10]

i had him lst year he does tend to start off slow start but worth all the cash in the end

[Alex7089]

I don't have Sylvia. People are after him because he plays for Melbourne and both of their byes are in non league rounds (multiple bye rounds.)
I have Green instead, who IMO is much better.