compliments and critisisim let me know

Started by ando_10, February 03, 2011, 07:56:43 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ando_10

backs goddard gibbs deledio broughton rawlings otten heppel
emg:cripps puopolo duigan

mids pendles burgoyne hayes anthony gaff harris
emg:atley hibberd smith

rucks sandi petrie
emg:campbell bailey

forwards chapman riewoldt  franklin green higgins knights krakeour
emg:prestia b.johnson mzungu

$10,400 left

a few uniques:

rawlings- i chose hime because he racks up the possies and he has a new role which i think will bring him more points

green- new captain i think he will step up to plate

burgoyne- if hes fit enough he can bring in some huge scores

let me know what you guys think and where this side needs to be improved

Luigi197

Quote from: ando_10 on February 03, 2011, 07:56:43 PM
backsgoddard gibbs deledio broughton rawlings otten heppel
emg:cripps puopolo duigan

midschapman pendles bartel foley gaff harris
emg:atley hibberd smith

ruckssandi petrie
emg:campbell bailey

forwardsriewoldt pavlich franklin brown higgins knights krakeour
emg:prestia b.johnson mzungu

8/10

nice backs.
ok mids but not a fan of 3 startin rookies, would prefer a mid-pricer instead of Harris
standard good rucks
good fwds

ando_10

i wouldnt class harris as a rookie so technically theres only 1 rookie in the mids
but i see where ya comin from

thescchamp

like this team but cant see brown being worth the pick, i no he is a gun, but he gets worn out to quickly as brisbane rely on him way to much and with some of their stars gone, this will put more pressure on him, also is injury prone...

although he could potentially rise in value over the first few weeks...

pardz


TheSituation

Situation is feelin what your sending out here my dude. Obvious question marks over starting with Brown given his history, however as has been mentioned he his what he is (a champion) and may rise in value. Not completley sold on Rawlings either, but he's a unique pick that could get the haters hatin...

tferrier18

Quote from: Luigi197 on February 03, 2011, 08:00:09 PM
ok mids but not a fan of 3 startin rookies
There's only 1 rookie in his mids?

Starting players like harris & krak this year and beau waters/maguire last year are such a good way of having rookie priced players (yes, i know krak isn't necessarily rookie priced) in your team but not actually adding to the risk of starting too many rookies. Saves you dosh and less risk!

That said, i don't like your mids (unless you're going for league win).
- 2 x geelong mids (you have i.smith on mids bench so you can put chapman in fwd line and still have mpp)

- like rawlings as a unique
- don't really like knights personally (but he's not a bad pick by any means...just my personal preference to have fwds that play mids)

8/10

Swallow12

8/10 best team ive seen on here so far, Mids are actually okay, however two geelong players may be a problem even if you are going for league. Also Brown is prob too risky for little reward at that price, better to wait and maybe upgrade later. But good team  :)

Jas 13

Concerned about your short term ruck cover on this one ando... Campbell still on rookie list at the Dees and Bailey coming back from 3rd knee reco and hasn't been training with the main group lately at the Hawks.

Spend the few $$$ to go Bailey to Zac Smith from GC if you can swing it...

greco272

Hey mate team looks pretty good, but my only real question is how do you think you'll go without a big gun like swan or ablett, do you rekcon this year you need those guys or maybe not....?

Adz23

you've got a interesting side here, you've got a good forward and back line structure, rucks decent tom only criticism would be your midline is a lil thin, it could probably do with another premium.  dont get me wrong you've still good a decent midfield but i think another premium might help :)

8.5/10