My team please rate and comment

Started by Jugganauts, February 02, 2011, 02:16:36 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Jugganauts

Back: Goddard, Delido, Gibbs, McMahon, Bower, C Bolton, Toy
(Faulks, Jacobs, Duigan)

Mids: Swann, Judd, Montanga, Cooney, Gaaf, D Swallow
(Heppell, Atley, Smith)

Rucks: Sandilands, Jolly
(Smith, Cordy)

Forwards: N Riewoldt, Pavlich, Brown, Murphy, Dangerfield, Petrie, Darling
(Dixon, Richardson, Mzungu)

Question: Should i have Dom Cassisi instead of Cooney?
Question: Should i move Gibbs into the midfield instead of Cooney and pick up Lake in defence?
Question: Should i have Dangerfield or Knights?
Question: Who would get more games Watson or Duigan from Carlton?

kazam

Backline is good, McMahon is somewhat unique, but can play, likewise with Bolton. Bower was ok when he played last year, but only fit in half the season because of his niggling injuries; make sure he appears over them for now.

Midfield is good, Gaff and Swallow should be good. Cooney dug me out of a few holes last year.

Rucks are fine, Cordy might even see some game time this year, if he can sneak ahead of Roughead, he may alread have Minson covered...

Forwards are pretty decent too, Mzungu might find himself on the field ahead of Darling. Just be careful of Petrie... over his injuries for the moment, but could hurt his foot again. Worth a stab for that price though.

Q1 - Possibly. You would need to compare their stats though and make an educated decision based on that, and their price.
Q2 - IMO, no.
Q3 - Iffy. I had the same problem. I think Knights' potential won it for me, I want to see him in 09 form. Although, Danger is a great player nonetheless and might find a bit more ball with the midfield absences.
Q4 - Don't know either too well. What I do know is that Watson is around 195cm and already built, around 95kg... Holds his own in a contest and Carlton are after a genuine CHB... He also has a penetrating long kick. From reports he can drill a 60m pass onto someones chest running out of defence with great composure. Might even consider him for my team.