Help Please

[Dolten101]

Guys a couple of questions first of all

Brougton or Duffield?

Also what is the best low priced player from the following players I will list below.

Foley, Mclean, Tambling, Houli, Kerr, Shuey

Also what are the best drafties for dreamteam?

Can you guys please give your Opinion
Regards Dolten

[elephants]

1)  I had a similar dillemma mate but i went with broughton. he is younger, and he has more upside in my opinion. i think he will get more mids time and 3rd year rule :)

2)  of those you have listed i would say Foley. mclean is an asshole (haha) and he will struggle in a young yet skilled carlton midfield, we will have to wait and see how tambling fits in at adelaide and if his scoring potential returns, houli is a back i am pretty sure and again we will have to wait and see where he is played at richmond, kerr just.... NO (i am an eagles supporter just trust me), shuey was a close second to foley. imo he is a gun and he will be in my team next year, he has been unlucky with injury and illness but i can see him really improving next year :)

3)  look around in the players and trades in dt section there are a lot of posts on rookies there :)

cheers LE

[popedelio]

: elephants  : Today at 03:49:59 PM 

1)  I had a similar dillemma mate but i went with broughton. he is younger, and he has more upside in my opinion. i think he will get more mids time and 3rd year rule

i disagree i reckon duffield will be the better option

Shuey is a shoe in for me over foley if he is healthy

[nas]

Duff for me hmm beer lol.

seriously tho Duff over Broughton.

If the Shoe fits well take him

[elephants]

yeah i was really thinking and i had typed my self out of picking foley hahaha yeah shuey probably and i think broughton will be better than duffs but only time will tell :)

[PowerMan]

Guys a couple of questions first of all

Brougton or Duffield?

Also what is the best low priced player from the following players I will list below.

Foley, Mclean, Tambling, Houli, Kerr, Shuey

Also what are the best drafties for dreamteam?

Can you guys please give your Opinion
Regards Dolten

Duffield was listed as a back in 2010, but he played mostly in the middle for Freo. If the same happens again in 2011 go for Duffield, which is expected.

[magpies01]

1) I would choose Duffield, because he seems to be more consistent.

2) None of them, they all seem crap, but if i had to choose one probalby Foley.

3) Swallow, Bennell, Gaff, Polec for midfield. Prestia, Matera, Tapscott for forward. Heppel, Mzungu, Ben Jacobs, Cripps, for backline. Sam Day and Zac Clarke are the best options for the ruck.[/glow]

[browny_wce]

1) Duff as a unique, everyone has Broughton, bu to be honest theres better players out there

2) Shuey - rookie priced after 3 years in the system, finished the year with a 100+ against the Cats

3) BACKS: Heppell, Jacobs, Toy, Smeldts, Mzungu, Richardson, O'Shea, Poupolo
    MIDS: Swallow, Gaff, Polec, Wallis, Caddy, Parker, Schroder, Atley
    RUCKS: Z.Smith, Lycett, Day, Daw, McDonald
    FWDS: Prestia, Lamb, Darling, Matera, Lynch, Cook

[elephants]

changed my descision :)

duffs :)

has been an integral part of my team for too long hahaha :)