Which is the best pre season team sc

[pie time]

Team 1: Fisher,Hodge,Duffield,J.Grimes,T.Hunt,Houli, C. Richardson
EMG: Otten, K.Hunt and Iles.

Swan,Goddard,Judd,Mundy,Hanneberry and D.Swallow
EMG: M.Sewell,M.Wallis and A.Krakouer

Petrie,Jolly
ENG: bailey and Spencer

Chapman, Roo,Gray,Thomas,Veszpremi,Pettard,B Sedts
EMG Hooper,Butcher and griffiths
$14400 left over

TEAM2: Goddard,Hodge,mDeledio,J.Grimes,K.Hunt,Houli
EMG Otten,Iles and C. Richardson

Swan.Montagna,Pendlebury,Hanneberry,D.Swallow,A.Krakouer
EMG I.Smith, Stanley and M. Sewell

Jolly, Trengrove EMG Z. Smith and Charman???

Chapman, Roo, Pettard,Stevie J,Veszpremi,Petrie,Sylvia
EMG Hooper,Daw and B. Matera
$84k left over

[Boofhead]

neither... :P

[pie time]

Come on Boof got to do better than that....

[Master Q]

neither... :P

[pie time]

Since there are no suggestions from the 2 responses i can only think that there is not a problem with either side which i find hard to believe...I don't mind negative feedback but reasons for it would be nice..

[Boofhead]

not enough rookies in the mids..in team one
trengrove
gray
hunt
average rucks..
just not feeling it  :P

[Master Q]

Rucks are horrible in both teams.

Don't see why you want Houli so badly, and Hunt???

[nas]

Can understand the Hunt for cash cow but there would be better around & Houli well you have to wait n see where he ends up

[Justin Bieber]

I'm no expert but I think:

Team 1 - Very Risky forwards. I don't mind the Rucks as Jolly plays for a good team (althoguh inconsistent) and Petrie at his best is a very solid fantasy player. Midfield is very stocked but I think you could skimp on 1 or 2 of those first 4 for rookies which will be just like this year with many to choose from. Can use this case to upgrade some of the second/third tier players in the team. Also, Taylor Hunt to get games in a strong Geelong Line up?

Team 2 - 3 Collingwood mids starting could mean trouble. Maybe change 1 of them. Rucks are pretty bad as Trengove is more of a KPP and shouldn't get much ruck time unless he has to play back up. Charman could be good if he moved. Doubt he'll get games at the Lions :(. Forwards alot better and backs are ok. I'm not sold on K. Hunt as if you watched his VFL games, didn't look like he could rack them up. Maybe good for 100k but would prefer another rookie who is more of a possession and running man. Missing a backman also ;).

[pie time]

Thanks for the feedback..I think Houli is worth the risk.. If he gets to Richmond he will play every game...Can get the ball and use it ok. Ave around 80 when he did play. Got to remember that the young big forwards and backs wont get much of a run and dont think there is many out there..

Players like K. hunt, Veszpremi, trengrove will all play early and will be used as trade bait and have a feeling T. hunt will play more this year.. Chapman is always injuried so will wait and see with him..The problem i see with all the gun midfielders is that they might end up at gold coast so am waiting for tomorrow night. Cheers guys..

[tferrier18]

Hunt will get games but I wouldn't count on vespremi playing week in week out.

Also, chapman had a pretty good year with injury in 2010, only missed 1 or 2 games and he didn't actually tear his hamstring so I think the risk with him has decreased a fair bit.

[Barlow 21]

Rucks are horrible in both teams.

Don't see why you want Houli so badly, and Hunt???

+1
Houli is okay but HUNT?

[pie time]

Updated teams
Fisher,hurn,duffield,grimes,houli,otten,richardson emg:Iles,watson,K.hunt
Swan,Goddard,Judd,Gaff,Hodge,D>Swallow emg Heppell,Atley,Krakouer
Petrie,Jolly EMG: DAY , Bailey
Chapman, Roo,Gray,Thomas,LeCras,Darling,Pettard EMG:Hooper,Matera,Butcher

Team 2
Goddard,Hodge,Duffield,Grimes,houli,Otten,Davis EMG K.Hunt,Illes,Richardson

Judd,Montagna,Pendles,Hannebery,Atley,D.Swallow EMG Stanley,Conca,Krakouer

Jolly,McIntosh EMG: Day and Daw

Chappy,Roo,Pettard,Stevie J,Darling,Hooper,Sylvia EMG Lamb,Matera & Cook

Please comment on which is best side now and comment on changes

[Barlow 21]

Want a Pie? ;D