Top 50 Players

[hawk_88]

Just checked out his list.

Johnson was picked at 40 so it is only 20 from 24.

Of those 24, I think he will leave out:

Kelly
Riewoldt, N
Shaw
Watson

Kelly and Watson just seems wrong to me. They should be there.


I don't know what Goodes and Scarlett are doing there. Would have Watson and Kelly over them based on this years performances.

[ossie85]

Agree, and I missed Johnson.

I'll be annoyed if Green's not there. Top 20 does seem high though

[Fletch74]

I think Mundy might miss from that list, and possibly Green, although it's not right. I think Kelly deserves to be in the Top 50, maybe not 20 though.

Also think that Enright and Cooney might miss top 20 from your list Ossie.

[hawk_88]

We are talking about Mike here though.... he always has some oddities. He has loved Green this year so I can't imagine he would miss, although I think top 20 is too high for him.

I expect Judd to be out of top 10, not because I would have him out but because Mike will.

[ossie85]

Mike Sheahan has Dale Thomas at #9! Crikey that's high. Thomas IMO is definately top 50 this year, but NUMBER NINE?!

Hodgey a bit low at #7

[Boomz]

some odd ones but overall its an alright top 50... Watson should be there.

[hawk_88]

For me Thomas is 40-50 at best. 9!!! Rubbish.