alan didak vs colin sylvia

[starz]

not sure who to have in my fwd line.
already have krak in there but not too concerned about that as i have cover for him and dids in round 7.

Dont really know how sylvia's pre season is tracking.
I do know that dids had surgery and is progressing well but i dont know if i should pick him from the start or an upgrade target

[reconfig]

Im picking sylvia on the in the hope he will explode this year

[dylsta05]

sylvia will do very well this year and so will melbourne

[starz]

Rank these two plus franklin in order from 1 to 3.
Me: 1 franklin
2 Sylvia
3 dids

Thoughts

[dylsta05]

Rank these two plus franklin in order from 1 to 3.
Me: 1 franklin
2 Sylvia
3 dids

Thoughts

\
same as mine!

[hardnut]

Yep I'm going Sylvia over Didak on the basis that maybe Sylvia can go up one more level should he play 22 rounds and crack the 100+ avg. I think Didak has peaked and will retain a very respectable mid 90's avg. If you've already got Kraks (like me) why create the double Collingwood headache - we don't know what rnd 1 will bring so wouldn't be too sure of cover for rnd 7

[ghostmonk]

Neither to begin with.  Didak's undergone fairly major surgery and is likely to come back underdone; Sylvia has average 16 games per year over the last 6 years.  Re-assess after round 5/7/13/16

[MTTY]

Didak as an upgrade target and Sylvia from the start for me