The Most Underated & Overated Players In AFL Thread.

[EAGLE4LIFE]

overrated justin koshtizke, leon davis, gary ablett, tom hawkins, brendan fevola, 'buddy' franklin, Kurt Tippet, Adam Cooney, Gumby
CYRIL RIOLI       

[elephants]

woah woah woah. are you trying to say garry ablett junior is overated!?!?!?!?!?!

agree with you on the rest except for buddy he is a gun. cooney dominated freo. seems to play well when the dogs are up.

[Master Q]

overrated justin koshtizke, leon davis, gary ablett, tom hawkins, brendan fevola, 'buddy' franklin, Kurt Tippet, Adam Cooney, Gumby
CYRIL RIOLI     

Agree but not with Cyril Rioli, he's good and young.

Gumby is improving, Ablett and Buddy are so overrated. Especially Buddy.

[Windigo]

Do you think Boyd is a better player than Cooney, like c'mon if Cooney can win a Brownlow.......

[Justin Bieber]

Boyd is much better ::). Cooney may of won a Brownlow as he is flashy. Boyd is a down to earth player who DOESN"T draw attention to himself. That's why he is so effective. Teams are too busy to shut down Cooney/Gilbee who are much easier to shut down so Boyd can be alot more damaging.

Last year Boyd played as both a tagger and the tagged. Scored either way :D.