Barlow to... Chappy?

[Stackilroy]

So I've got Ziebell and Barlow... I'm thinking of trading Barlow to Chappy... and then swapping him forward for Ziebell... then upgrading Ziebell to a solid mid, along the lines of Judd or even Corey if i can afford him. Does this work? If so, does it sound smart? I have Swan Bartel and Montagna already, along with Joel Selwood and Jobe Watson. Is chappy a risk in terms of an injury or getting rested? I hate not having Chappy, he's obscenely consistent.

[brodman_18]

Sounds smart but how many trades do you have left? If you did that, would you still bre able to get Roo when he bottoms out?

[ossie85]

Good plan :)

[RiOtChEsS]

yeah it works  but do u really want to take the chance on chappy at this time of year? why not just trade barlow to ur solid mid now and get roo when he bottoms out in 2-3 weeks, should be 50k cheaper than chappy at his bottom dollar

[JamesBadge]

Trading Barlow to a solid mid, and Ziebel to Chappy would achieve the exact same outcome would it not? Is the subbing of Chappy from mid to fwd necessary. Admittedly, it does seem fancier. Brilliant even...

[JamesBadge]

So yeah, it does sound smart...but it's actually the complete opposite.

[Sharker18]

Trading Barlow to a solid mid, and Ziebel to Chappy would achieve the exact same outcome would it not? Is the subbing of Chappy from mid to fwd necessary. Admittedly, it does seem fancier. Brilliant even...

i was thinking the same thing  ;D im sure he impressed some people though

[the_jackal]

yeah... he didnt impress me. some people want to seem all savy by using the MPP option. just keep it simple you dud

[JamesBadge]

I think Stackilroy is actually being funny. Joking, in a 'cleverer-than-us sense to see who is actually reading and who is just skimming in a race to reply. Stakilroy doesn't laugh at farts.  :-X