Goodes Judd!!!

[Stirling]

Trading Martin for either Judd or goodes any ideas???? Goodes is dpp aswell

[Johnnysd]

Goodes by a mile

[browny_wce]

juddy more consistent, goodesy is cheaper i think
wuld probably try for a better upgrade in the mids then those two tho
whos in ur mids?

[my.tbt]

Go Judd, avg. 106 for $400k... Consistent and a bargain  at that price. Goodes historically a strong season finisher but more inconsistent. Both good choices, but Judd is my pick!

Ive got Goodes.

[LaHug]

Obviously too late for this round now, but Goodes by a long shot (especially if you have a DPP like Pav or ROK in the forwards)!

[Stirling]

thanks guys to late now but my midfield is abb swan mitchell cross selwood and martin. I decide to go judd as he wont get rested and hopefully will finish off strong as carlton need him to get into tho finals. Also i checked the next four games of goodes and judd and goodes avg around 70 out of 18ish games   against his next four teams where judd avgs 90 in all 4. I thought all this was better than goodes dpp ability

[Davoo]

goodes wont be rested