Who to offload..Maguire or Davis?

[Slammer]

G'day all,

Can someone please help me.
Who should I offload out of Maguire and P.Davis after both will be out for a while.
This week have Kennelly, Davis and Goose sidelined with only Webberley as cover so will cop a donut if I don't trade.
Have 10 trades left and was thinking Howlett -> Gysberts and then either P.Davis or Maguire for Gilbert/Gilbee or Fisher (leaning towards Gilbert). Then have Webberley as cover until Kennelly gets back. Maguire trade would leave me with more $$ but Maguire maybe better reserve than Davis in run to finals?? Also would Shuey & gysberts be enough cover for mids. (JS)

Any thought? Here is my team:

Backs: Hodge, Malceski, Hurn, Enright, O'Brien, kennelly, Maguire
subs: Webberley, davis
Mids: Ablett, Swan, Goddard, Bartel, Goodes, Barlow
subs: Howlett, Shuey
Rucks: Clark, Naitinui
subs: Warnock, Lobbe
Fwds: Brown, ROK, Didak, Pavlich, Franklin, Pods, Rockcliff
subs: Watts, Tippett

[Master Q]

Maguire is more of a keeper, unlike Davis who is just there for Injuries, Maguire would be the better trade as you wouldn't really want to start someone around the Davis Price Range.

[McRooster]

Maguire because of the $ and the length of layoff. Bench stalwart Davis will be back soon, keep him as cover.

[Alex7089]

Yeah Maguire can be brought out for a premium so he's the one to go for me. Don't want to get rid of Davis for a player who will score poorly and you may eventually want to trade them back out again.