Hamish McIntosh

Started by Connect 4, June 01, 2010, 07:05:11 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Trade him or not?

Mcintosh --> Sandi
2 (25%)
Mcintosh --> cox
0 (0%)
wait for a few weeks
6 (75%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Connect 4

worth trading him up to Sandi this week?
i have 33,100 in the bank and have

McIntosh Hille (Trengove and Warnock) as my rucks
Have 12 trades left
Was thinking of downgrading warnock to some 77 grand fellow then upgrading McIntosh? Good idea or wait a bit because im playing a couple of pretty average teams in my league

Justin Bieber

McIntosh should be a keeper. Been under an injury cloud past few weeks = form slump.

He did start the year at 390k (i think) for a reason.

Saying this, would wait and see if he can find form first. He should if he can overcome that injury of his. Hurting me as well but Keeping A Little Faith (Had to throw that in seeing as I haven't said it for a while)

McRooster

Quote from: Hellopplz on June 01, 2010, 09:57:13 PM
McIntosh should be a keeper. Been under an injury cloud past few weeks = form slump.

He did start the year at 390k (i think) for a reason.

Saying this, would wait and see if he can find form first. He should if he can overcome that injury of his. Hurting me as well but Keeping A Little Faith (Had to throw that in seeing as I haven't said it for a while)
Averages well against teams North finishes season against, so if you'r e going for league win - hold on!

DevilsReject

#3
I currently have Sandilands and H-Mac with Trengove and Warnock on the bench. My question is, do you think McIntosh will improve and begin scoring like he used to? Or will Goldstein effectively strangle H-Mac's scores for the rest of the season? I can do a direct trade to Mumford, or by trading Vince to Goodes (and opening up MPP support) I can trade H-Mac to Kreuzer of Clark.

10 trades left, 20k in the bank

jvalles

Stick by hmac unless LTI, would be sideways trade.  I have Hille and Hmac and sticking by both of them.

Justin Bieber

Got the exact same ruck combo. Keeping A Little Faith Hmac can regain good form even with Goldy there.

Hmac to Mummy seems a bit too sideways. But if you really think that Hmac can't score, then go. But i would suggest hang on a little longer. Already lost alot of cash. Not going to get your moneys worth now if you don't upgrade.

McRooster

Possibly my final trade prior to rnd 22, H Mac tonned it up against Melb earlier this year and if fit can see him doing it again with possible spot in 8 for the Roos up for grabs.