Ziebell to Tippett - Crazy but could work!!!

[Piggers]

I know this may sound crazy but Tippett and the crows could not do much worse and he was a good player last year and really should be this year!!!
Ziebell has really let me down, wasnt expecting 100+ each week but also wasnt expecting the shower scores he has put up so far!!! Cant see him improving any time soon!!! Wanted him to make money in my side not sit there stagnant and losing money.
Tippett is at rock bottom and can do better than what Ziebell is putting up!!! Classic case of risk vs reward wgat are peoples thoughts!!!

[carpsi]

Only half your comment is correct.

Yes to "crazy"
No to "but could work"

[Cruiseon]

B grade player to B grade player?  - I think you're having a laugh.

[bottlemart]

I like Ziebel as a player and I think he be good in years to come, but being a second year player, I didn't pick him in my team, because at $320k or whatever he cost, I think there was better value elsewhere, and second year players don't generally score well in SC.  He gets the ball a bit and is capable of good scores such as 100 in round 1 in a losing side, but I think his disposal lets him down at the moment.

Tippet is also capable, but if I were doing an upgrade, i would be looking at the premium end of the market, and tippet is in the same boat as ziebel, where he will still be capable of letting you down at times.

If you are trading out Ziebel, either go for a $100k rookie, or a $500k plus premium.   

[mattpedo]

i think this injury to anthony could mean more tog and more midfield opportunitys for jZ

dont write him off yet

[Blueboys]

I know this may sound crazy but Tippett and the crows could not do much worse and he was a good player last year and really should be this year!!!
Ziebell has really let me down, wasnt expecting 100+ each week but also wasnt expecting the shower scores he has put up so far!!! Cant see him improving any time soon!!! Wanted him to make money in my side not sit there stagnant and losing money.
Tippett is at rock bottom and can do better than what Ziebell is putting up!!! Classic case of risk vs reward wgat are peoples thoughts!!!

And West coast can win the flag this year! Call me crazy but it could work!  ::)

[Alex7089]

No way he was playing Richmond so you automatically take 30 points off his score and that would be what he would get against any other team.

[Didds70]

Ah well Piggers , i'll join you in being crazy , although i went sideways from Seaby to Tippett , scheizen form to date no doubt about that & the only way , surely is up for this bloke , he can still have an influence & score well as an individual , FFSake Richmond are gone but there's still players there scoring ok (just) .

[moses]

Good move.
Ziebell may improve with no Anthony but he may also cop a tag.  He can hardly get a touch without a tag!
Tippett on the other hand will come into form at some stage and is too cheap to ignore. Particularly if you can swap him between Ruck and Forward.