Trades for next round..

[imessenger]

Guys,

Need some help with trades this week.  I have around 260k cashola, and looking at the following trades -

1. Watson (389) to Swan (470) (figure best time is now to pick him up)
2. Roughead (282) to Didak (387) (seeing his down a fair bit, but also considering Goodesy/Pav/O'keefe (others?)

Roughy killed me last week, you reckon i should hang on to him or pull the trigger?? he looked pretty average in that game..

Plus i have mitchell prob with a donut again this week so maybe nows the time for a couple of trades you reckon?

Let me know what you think, or any other suggestions would be awesome

Cheers!

[Spooners]

roughie out for someone, i think pav would be more likely
i think getting swan just means you have the same team as everyone else, id pick stanton over him any day.. great form, great player, less popular
there are a lot of good 380-430k mids atm, should look into them

[benjy251090]

what is your whole team to see if there is a better option?

[imessenger]

Thanks guys my team is:

hodge, carazzo, enright, malceski, waters, maguire, silvagni (hunt, hams)

bartel, dal, barlow, watson, jack, mitchell, (shuey, banner)

sandi, hille, (warnock, lobbe)

brown, gia, higgins, brennan, balla, roughie, pods (gumby, danger)

Spooners, i was also looking into gibbs, but my gut still says swan, dont want to take a risk on stanton...

[benjy251090]

i would look at your backline first, their seem to be a lot of cash cows there that good do with some upgrading, could do with a straight swap of like a hunt to hargrave and then maybe look at watson or roughie after that

[elxam]

Can't see any sense in trading your cash cows this rd.
Also, can't see the point of sideways watson and swan.

[thornz23]

i would leave watson alone for the moment u have more important things to worry about. according to another thread mitchel said on a radio show today that he was unlikely to play this week again. So with that in mind... if u already have 260k i would be looking to downgrade hunt on ure bench to someone like P davis(although u have already missed the boat) or even roberton from freo.. he has only played one game so far so you won;t see an increase in price for another 2 but if he is named this week.. could be a good option. Then i would look to upgrade banner with ure 260k +  what u make off the hunt downgrade.
u might have 360k or so and could upgrade banner to montagna/swan or anyone under and save some cash.

alternatively if u are willing to cop the donut this week ure bacline needs more attention in which case i would still downgrade hunt this week and next week u could perhaps upgrade one of silvagni and maguire/waters and do the other upgrade this week....

So there u go food for thought :P

[maccar86]

stantons not a risk...

stanton for a unique pick (not many teams have him, will still avg over 100)

swan like everyone else (prob will avg same as stanton) but has more proven DT scores

[browny_wce]

i wuld be reluctant to be so keen on swan, he hasnt done much to show me that he wuld be a must to bring into the team
plus im with exlam watson -> swan is too sideways, look at upgrading and keeping watto, he can score 100s consistently
roughy is gona be a roughy, culd be one of those 40 one week 140 the next type players, and think he did play on fletcher on the weekend n looked sore from the ruck the week before, against the eagles he will probably line up against mackenzie as glass shud goto buddy, so think he wuld kick a bag.
i would look to upgrade maguire or silvagni 1st then look for cover for mitchell this week...trust me he wont play, unless hawks really want the win (they wont fly a semi-injured mitchell-particularly with a bung hammy-over to perth to play an out of form, young west coast midfield)