Gilbee vs Gilbert

[rusty4u]

Just one more upgrade/downgrade to complete my backline. I can afford a premium.. Tossing up between Gilbee and Gilbert? What's everyones views? Before Gilbee's big score, Gilbert was probably scoring a bit better.. They both have pretty similiar runs coming up.. decisions decisions..

[Flame]

i'm a big fan of glbert..if I had the coin I would get him!!

[browny_wce]

yeh gilbee did look alrite on the weekend n looks to back to his DT form from a few years back
but then again gilbert is racking up some monster scores aswell

[elxam]

have had gilbee in the last two years and has been super consistent so far.
Gilbert is foreign to me. sorry

[Andrew]

What about Grimes for this week? Discounted heavily.

[maccar86]

i like gilbee over gilbert and not just for last weeks scores.

i think gilbee is taking the hargrave role (best kick in the afl) and the bulldogs look for him at every opp. when they hit their straps i see him averaging 100 all year

[Juddster5]

Gilbees kick isn't the best Josh Drummond owns him anyday

[Justin Bieber]

Gilbees kick isn't the best Josh Drummond owns him anyday

Got to throw Hurn into the mix as well. Top 3 in the AFL.

Gilbee or Gilbert is a real tough one. Gilbee is playing off half back while Gilbert is allowed to run off half back. They both can get a hell of alot of possessions. Gilbee has been able to handle the tag a bit better this year and has been proven over many years.
Tough call but i'd go Gilbee but nothing really in it for me.

[brodman_18]

While teams continue to flood their deffence against the dogs, Gilbee will dominate

[elxam]

Gilbert has stepped up this year but Gilbee has been consistently there and about for much longer

[thornz23]

Gilbees kick isn't the best Josh Drummond owns him anyday

Got to throw Hurn into the mix as well. Top 3 in the AFL.

Gilbee or Gilbert is a real tough one. Gilbee is playing off half back while Gilbert is allowed to run off half back. They both can get a hell of alot of possessions. Gilbee has been able to handle the tag a bit better this year and has been proven over many years.
Tough call but i'd go Gilbee but nothing really in it for me.

I reckon top 3: drummond, hurn, davey
And for the trade i would be going gilbert over gilbee. gilbee only got such a massive score last week because the doggies where chipping it around so much trying to break the saints defence. While gilbert is one of the saints go to men, gets an assload of marks n kicks every game. He is ure man

[Bluke]

Gilbert for me.. Leads the league in marks at the moment.

[GinoGod]

Gilbert u get you around 80+ every match.
Gilbee can get anywhere between 60-100+. his up and down with dream team