Vince - Gibbs or Mitchell - Judd

Started by Hazza09, May 01, 2010, 12:08:52 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Hazza09

Im stuck in between these two trade options. Dont know how serious Mitchell's injury is and am thinking of trading him for Judd.
I have also run out of patience with Vince and i could trade him for Gibbs.

I have Martin & Mitchell so i will cop a 0 if i dont trade.

I Have 104k in the bank

Options are:

Vince - Gibbs
Shuey - JKT

or

Mitchell - Judd
Dangerfield - Davis

I want to keep Mitchell though as he has more to offer than Vince.


Fletch74

SIDEWAYS. Either downgrade a trade like Danger to Davis, or upgrade like Danger to Gibbs.

Hazza09

Why is this a sideways trade?

Danger is in my forward line....

Wouldnt upgrading danger to Goodes etc be an upgrade?

Downgrading Danger to Davis is SIDEWAYS....
Trading Vince to Gibbs is a good trade, because one is in form and one clearly isnt.

Fletch74

Because you're trading a Premium for another premium. You only have 20 trades. You picked Vince at the start, unless he has a LTI you should not trade him. You picked him as a keeper, not as someone to offload.

Your decision mate, but you'll regret come round 16 or so when you have no trades left because of form!

Danger to Goodes - upgrade - yes
Danger to Davis - Downgrade to get some $$$
Vince to Gibbs - SIDEWAYS
Mitchell to Judd - SIDEWAYS