Davis or Hams?

Started by PorkSwords, April 26, 2010, 12:52:13 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

PorkSwords

Who has more job security, Phil Davis or Ashton Hams?

ELLsendon

I'd say Phil Davis, as he was a high draft pick.

Hams could just be one of those Cale Hookers, who suprises everyone and plays a lot of games in the year, it's a tough one.

Plastic Boy

Phil Davis looks pretty handy for a skinny stick, he looks very comfortable in the back pocket, holding it while Ottens is out

woofy

so is davis holding ottens or bocks spot? how long is otten out for? his running now i think?

cheers

Plastic Boy

Ottens was ruled out for the season, he went for the traditional knee recon rehab.

No threat of davis losing spot

woofy

cool thanks for the info. cant trade him in though. nason hasnt finished making me money. dayummm

mdm90

i would go for Hams over Davis because Hams is playing up forward and he hasnt got competition for the small/half forward spot. while Davis is playing because the crows are missing Bock and Stevens and i reckon that neil craig will play Stevens over Davis IMO

elxam

kerr is out for while so hams looks more likely too

browny_wce

hams is like that stevie milne/ballantyne sort of player so eagles shud keep him in as something different in the forward line
davis is only really holding a spot i recon, if bock comes back he'll be out

elxam

yeah hams has the physique and quickness ...hope he's going to be a crumber in the forward for the eagles

ridley

hams may go out when shuey comes back. they rate shuey so highly at west coast