Judd vs Boyd

[snudz]

Not withstanding Boyd's current hand injury, who would be the better option...Judd or Boyd?

[wooly]

both are stars, but if I had to pick one it would be boyd simply cos judd will almost certainly cop the no.1 tag each week, whilst boyd won't. In saying that there arent many taggers who can slow judd down.

[Justin Bieber]

Tough one. Personally, i'd go boyd. Been on that train for 4 years.

Probably a coin toss in general. Both are ball magnets. Judd gets tagged often while Boyd also cops a tag every now and again (but isn't effected too much either). Boyd is very durable though but Judd is also ???

[Carnthedockers]

Boyd. Judd is traditionally not a great dream teamer..

[Mish]

in other words try get both on your team :)

[Fletch74]

Boyd. Judd is traditionally not a great dream teamer..

Agree. Boyd is traditionally far better than Judd. Judd is better at SC.

[snudz]

The voting is locked at 50% each! Tough call this one. I can't get both in my team. My Midfield looks like this:
Ablett
Swan
Barlow
Selwood
Johnstone
Trengove
Martin
...........

Either Boyd or judge will fill the void....

[browny_wce]

who u thinking of trading for?

[bundyboy]

boyd for DT and Judd for SC

but gee, i don't think there is much in it..

[snudz]

who u thinking of trading for?

browny WCE, I have tossed a coin on this for the last few weeks and it lands on it's side each time. I'm really after your opinion on this one :)