Hille and Clarke out - thoughts on this trade???

[plugger36]

Currently my ruckmen are Hille and Clark and i want to get rid of Clark for Sandi but i only have 300 in the bank...

I was thinking on doing:

hille ---- Seaby/Nic Nat
Clark---- SANDI
with 18 trades left

then when seaby or nic nat are the right price for me  i can do a sideways trade for Cox...

opinions on this trade???

[guru2]

ur thinking the same thing as everyone else!! probly a good option tho

[plugger36]

Forgot to add which would be the better option???

seaby

or

NicNat???

[guru2]

cox seems to have some sort of problem maybe an injury, which could be very good for naitanui's scores if he becomes the only ruckmen

[valkorum]

So its gonna cost you 3 trades to get 2 premium rucks in your team.  You need to ask yourself is it worth the trades.

[yorgis]

can't see seaby keeping up those numbers for long but  imo he will make you some cash, as with nic nat . if you've got the cash i'd go kruze

[bailey_minis]

Keep Hille. His value hasn't even moved so what's the point of getting him? Wait a few rounds for his price to move up, then if it looks to have stopped (or is going to go down) only then trade him.

As for Clarke, I have no answers. Usually I'd say don't trade a player after 2 games, but he's just been so bad and for that price tag....

Up to you in the end mate.

[numberwang]

Keep Hille. His value hasn't even moved so what's the point of getting him? Wait a few rounds for his price to move up, then if it looks to have stopped (or is going to go down) only then trade him.

As for Clarke, I have no answers. Usually I'd say don't trade a player after 2 games, but he's just been so bad and for that price tag....

Up to you in the end mate.

Agreed. Can't believe people want to trade Hille.
Clark is gone for me. I've broken my no trade rule for him. L berger will see to it that even after he regains his fitness, he'll only be 3/4 of clark circa 2009 - whenever that will be.

I think Seaby has more going for him than most think. He'll avg 80 this year and as the secondary ruck on my team, that suits me just fine.

Cox will not reach his former self - this year he hands the batten to Nic.

[plugger36]

Should I do the following trade to get big Sandilands???

Rockliff ---- Peterson
Clark ---- Sandi

My forwards at present is ROK, ROO, Lockyer, GIA, Hall, Mayne,Rocklif?? (Gumby, Pods)

My other ruck is Hille???

[Cicjose]

now everyone will need to make a trade this week with Riewoldt tearing his hamstring off the bone against Collingwood in tonight's game

[Flame]

I'll complete my first trade this week..Roo - ???