Joel or Joel?? plus more!

[sainters]

Having Selection troubles... I think a lot will hinge on the round 1 teams.. but just asking for some one name/word answers... or if you feel like explaining your choices that'd be great... Any replies appreciated.

1. Joel Selwood (404k) or Joel Corey (485k)? (Who will average more?)
2. Best Premium Forward Combination - 3 selections. $1,272,000 to spend.
3. Best Ruck (considering points AND value) from Petrie (374k) down.
4. Best Defender - Excluding: Hodge, Bowden, Goddard, Cornes, Lockyer
5. R.Houlihan (244k). Yes or No?
6. D.Mundy (312k). Yes or No?
7. J.Geary (192k). Yes or No?
8. H.Taylor (261k). Yes or No?
9. T.Cloke (334k). Yes or No?
10. N.Krakouer (189k). Yes or No?
11. S.Sidebottom (110k). Yes or No?

sorry there's so many!!

[love4thegame]

1) joel selwood
2) Deledio, Pavlich, Goodwin maybee.. alot to select from.
3) Sandilands or McIntosh
4) Fisher
5) No
6) There is better at that price
7) Yes, grimes is better though
8. Not for me
9) Yes
10) No.. maybe for others just not me

[hibbo]

1) Corey average more but will he maintain his price- doubtful.
2) Chappy, N Brown, Pavlich/Deledio
3) Sandilands- will average 85+
4) Fisher
5) Yes- good scores in the past and will rise in value
6) Maybe- wait till his role is certain
7) No- not secure a 22 spot
8) Probs not- unless mackie and him reverse roles, which 99% wont happen.
9) Yes, Should be a break out year.
10) A risk. But could work out...no for me though.

[stuballers]

1) Corey for best ave, Selwood for value
2) Can't decide
3) Petrie, Sandilands
4) Fisher
5) Yes
6) No
7) No
8) No
9) N0
10) Yes
11) No, later in the season possibly.

[sainters]

cheers! to the others.. please keep the replies coming!

I'm gonna go with Selwood for the $$

At this point, I'm going with Deledio, Gia and N.Brown. But this will probably change numerous times leading up to the lockout.

I guess I'm looking for a ruck that will increase in value in the first 5-6 rounds as I feel Cox's price will have dropped by then. I plan to get Cox.. just not at 473k.

I'm not so sure about Sam Fisher right now, because with Max Hudghton injured AND Matt Maguire still not ready for round 1, he might take on a key defensive role. When they come back I agree with you.

As for the rest... it's so frustrating as there are sooooo many value picks this season and you obviously can't have them all.

[wce2009]

1. Joel Corey will average more
2. deledio johnson buddy
3. mcintosh
4. fisher
5. yes
6. no
7. no
8. no
9. yes
10. maybe.. depends on structure
11. not yet

[hibbo]

On Fisher

Remember last year he had no Maguire next to him and Hudghton injured for some games and he still averaged 90. Saints will throw Blake back to take the number 1 forward while the others are out. And there has been talk that Fisher along with goddard will send some time on ball. All in all Fisher will average 90+ again.

[Scratchy]

1) corey average higher but not by 20 ppg which is what his price suggests
2) s. johnson, pavlich, chapman (if concerned by injury then go n. brown)
3) petrie
4) mackie
5) yes
6) no
7) no
8) no
9) yes, i can't get him but i think he'll pay off
10) yes
11) i think he and beams would both be in the top 5 of first year players (DT potential-wise), but i'm extremely concerned about how many games they'll get. i'm almost thinking get both or neither?

[nambo]

1. J.Corey (cheap disposals)
2. B.Deledio, M.Pavlich, A.Didak (?)
3. S.Fisher (then A.Mackie)
4. Who is Ryan Houlihan?
5. Ditto
6. Ditto
7. and ditto.
8. preferbly not...
9. better money spent elsewhere...
10. Yes (?) but i didnt...


And that's my two cents.