RDT: Player X vs. Player Y

[Koop]

Will start this off for the year.

Ross v Macrae v Lyons v Coniglio v Oliver? 

[Ringo]

Would rank in this order

Coniglio, Macrae, Lyons, Oliver and Ross.  Not a real lot between any of them.

Coniglio - Last week was his lowest score for the season but has easy draw with games against Freo, Sts and Brisbane in next 3 rounds. With 120 this week will rise another $29k.
Macrae - Surprise packet in a woeful Dogs outfit. Will he continue to rack them up or will Bont get more mid time to take some points off him.  This little uncertainty drops him to second.
Lyons - Bye the put off here but if you can cover well worth a look.  He seems to be the one benefiting from Gazzs departure at Suns and with further injury to Hanley will be main in mids. has a B/e of only 32 here and with another ton will rise $40k
Oliver - Had colours well and truly lowered by the No 1 tagger in game in Ben Jacobs but prior to that was very sound. has hard draw over the next 2 weeks in Hawks and Tigers which may get him back on track.
Ross - Stand out in Saints season to date. Concern is if Billings given more mid time (Armitage not cutting it at the moment) will effect Ross's scoring.

Brief summary but in my opinion can not go wrong with any.

[Ricochet]

Will start this off for the year.

Ross v Macrae v Lyons v Coniglio v Oliver?

Macrae would probably be my pick

[Rusty00]

Trying to decide between these two, it’s a tough choice at the moment

Keeping playing vs Delete team

:'(

[TomK]

Trying to decide between these two, it’s a tough choice at the moment

Keeping playing vs Delete team

:'(

Delete team for sure. Much more reliable.

[Ricochet]

Trying to decide between these two, it’s a tough choice at the moment

Keeping playing vs Delete team

:'(

Delete team for sure. Much more reliable.

And much more consistent. Pretty much set and forget too

[Rusty00]

Trying to decide between these two, it’s a tough choice at the moment

Keeping playing vs Delete team

:'(

Delete team for sure. Much more reliable.

And much more consistent. Pretty much set and forget too

Thanks for the advice guys. Might just wait until teams drop on Thursday and then pull the trigger :P

[Chelskiman]

Trading out Armo this week but undecided between Coniglio or Gibbs.  I can go Gibbs but be left with just 11k or I could go Conigs and be left with 146k.

Thoughts?

[Ringo]

Basically depends on what you do with the 146K. Gibbs has the dreaded Rd 14 bye as well to consider if you are heavy there.

Gibbs has the higher B/e as well and will only go up marginally if achieved whereas Nigs will go up around 30k.

Both would be keepers so probably toss a coin. I grabbed Nigs for Ablett but with cash went Ryan to Buddy.

[Chelskiman]

Yeah, I was leaning more towards Conigs anyway.  He's scoring just as well as Gibbs and whilst I don't have any immediate plans for the cash I'd rather have it sitting there than not. 

[Koop]

Jack Macrae or Bryce Gibbs?

[Ringo]

Toss a coin - Gibbs has a B/e of 119 and Macrae a B/e of 86 so can be expected to rise about 15k.

Will Gibbs start to attract a tag rather than Sloane if he continues his form is the real question?

Macrae just in front of Gibbs for me.

[Chelskiman]

Long term Gibbs I think, but if you're just looking short term (money + points) then Macrae.  I think Gibbs will average more than him at the end of the season, but you really can't go wrong with both at this point.

[Ricochet]

Jack Macrae or Bryce Gibbs?

I'm going with Gibbs