Round 6 Trades

[essendon2]

This week:
Spencer --> Balic
D. Swallow --> Hibberd

Next week:
Taranto --> Black
WHE --> JPK

[Ringo]

I would trade WHE to the best mid you can afford. Will mean you will be only carrying one rookie in mids,

Which mid would you rather get?

Martin, JPK or Wines

Thank you in advance

I think JPK is about to get going, along with a few other Sydney mids.

Dusty will be a lot cheaper in about 2 weeks I think so would prefer to wait at least a week on him.

Wines with the bye coming up isn't as appealing.

Yep JPK now, Dusty in 2 weeks and if you want wines after the bye.

[Hazza09]

I'm still not sold on hanners therefore option 2.... hanners role just doesn't look concrete to me and I'd want that out of a super premo mid!! Macrae will be in the top Fwds no questions so that's the direction I'd head
[/quote]

So will Hannerby be a top 8/9 midfielder by the seasons end?
i know its a difficult question to answer but this is the only thing that is worrying me about picking him up this week.

Currently my midfield is: Dangerfield, Fyfe, JPK, Treloar, Adams, Beams, O’Meara, Swallow.

Now Swallow will go this week for Hannerby, leaving me with Adams (Will go back in defence), O’Meara and potentially Beams to upgrade. Thats 3 midfield spots.

Still have no Bont, Dusty, Selwood, Sloane or Rockliff who potentially could all be top 8 midfielders this season.

so this is my only reason why I’m a little hesitant going hannerby. I could also go McCrae in the forwards or move Nankervis to the fwd line via WHE and bring in Grundy as R2.

So unsure which way to go….

[tommy10]

Not sure which way to go:

1. Roughy and Swallow > Balic and Fisher & $533k in bank, then next week upgrade SPP to Pendles and Pickett to Black, but will play 2 of Butler/Parfitt/Balic on field. Might still have about $350k (depending on what Pendles gets this week) for week after upgrade to do Marchbank to Docherty.
2. Swallow and Pickett > Balic and Fisher & $311k in bank, then next week JOM and SPP to Pendles and Black
3. Swallow and Roughy > Fisher/Balic (miss out on one of them) and Buddy (could go huge n the next 2-3 games) & $186k-$190k depending on whether I get Balic/Fisher. Then I could either do double downgrade next week and get Melican/McNeice/EVW and Black.
Have 6 premo mids, with JOM and Swallow in M7 & M8 respectively. Roughy is F5 and playing Butler at F6.

The answer will be determined by whether points this week matter a lot

I usually prefer to grab one premium at times like this as long astray are cheapish like say Rocky or Selwood this week

Roughy has to go this week and Swallow has not been a winner

Kinda going for overall as I'm in the top 1%, so thinking of Buddy and Balic for Roughy and Swallow. Will still have enough for SPP and JOM to Pendles and Black next week.

[tkringle]

Not sure which way to go:

1. Roughy and Swallow > Balic and Fisher & $533k in bank, then next week upgrade SPP to Pendles and Pickett to Black, but will play 2 of Butler/Parfitt/Balic on field. Might still have about $350k (depending on what Pendles gets this week) for week after upgrade to do Marchbank to Docherty.
2. Swallow and Pickett > Balic and Fisher & $311k in bank, then next week JOM and SPP to Pendles and Black
3. Swallow and Roughy > Fisher/Balic (miss out on one of them) and Buddy (could go huge n the next 2-3 games) & $186k-$190k depending on whether I get Balic/Fisher. Then I could either do double downgrade next week and get Melican/McNeice/EVW and Black.
Have 6 premo mids, with JOM and Swallow in M7 & M8 respectively. Roughy is F5 and playing Butler at F6.

The answer will be determined by whether points this week matter a lot

I usually prefer to grab one premium at times like this as long astray are cheapish like say Rocky or Selwood this week

Roughy has to go this week and Swallow has not been a winner

Kinda going for overall as I'm in the top 1%, so thinking of Buddy and Balic for Roughy and Swallow. Will still have enough for SPP and JOM to Pendles and Black next week.

I'm top 1% as well (637th) and struggling with the double downgrade vs one up one down decision..

Going one up one down means I could only afford Hanners as a mid prem and leaves little in the way of extra $$. Tempted to double downgrade which means I can then comfortably one up and one down for a few weeks in a row.. ARGHH

[tommy10]

Not sure which way to go:

1. Roughy and Swallow > Balic and Fisher & $533k in bank, then next week upgrade SPP to Pendles and Pickett to Black, but will play 2 of Butler/Parfitt/Balic on field. Might still have about $350k (depending on what Pendles gets this week) for week after upgrade to do Marchbank to Docherty.
2. Swallow and Pickett > Balic and Fisher & $311k in bank, then next week JOM and SPP to Pendles and Black
3. Swallow and Roughy > Fisher/Balic (miss out on one of them) and Buddy (could go huge n the next 2-3 games) & $186k-$190k depending on whether I get Balic/Fisher. Then I could either do double downgrade next week and get Melican/McNeice/EVW and Black.
Have 6 premo mids, with JOM and Swallow in M7 & M8 respectively. Roughy is F5 and playing Butler at F6.

The answer will be determined by whether points this week matter a lot

I usually prefer to grab one premium at times like this as long astray are cheapish like say Rocky or Selwood this week

Roughy has to go this week and Swallow has not been a winner

Kinda going for overall as I'm in the top 1%, so thinking of Buddy and Balic for Roughy and Swallow. Will still have enough for SPP and JOM to Pendles and Black next week.

I'm top 1% as well (637th) and struggling with the double downgrade vs one up one down decision..

Going one up one down means I could only afford Hanners as a mid prem and leaves little in the way of extra $$. Tempted to double downgrade which means I can then comfortably one up and one down for a few weeks in a row.. ARGHH

Nice one on the ranking. I'm giving Hanners a miss as I have JPK already and it also means having to field two fwd rookies. I could also go Swallow and Pickett to Balic and Fisher but will miss out on points which may push me further away from the leaders but also Roughy seems unlike to reach BE and will lose cash.

Arrrggghh... this is driving me insane  :-\