WestCoasting Team of 17 V1

[BigPeen]

Hey Guys

I cant wait for the first bounce down! I was on this site as MelbEagle last year but lost my login details, so here I am as a new user.

Would love your feedback on my first draft -

[uncleswagy]

Hey Guys

I cant wait for the first bounce down! I was on this site as MelbEagle last year but lost my login details, so here I am as a new user.

Would love your feedback on my first draft -

do like it for the most part

curious on the reasonings behind gaff and smith, what are you seeing their outputs as being, dont see gaff as coming close to a top 10 mid this year personally.

and also as someone who had jack steven last year, word of warning, his inconsistency will give you headaches and possibly heart attacks if your over the age of 65

[PureSwag]

Gaff??? I think maybe getting a gray or a bont are betting around that price even going down to Murphy or beams.

Issacc? Just don't think he can be a top 10 fwd in supercoach

Steven?????? Up and down like I said gray bont or go down to a Murphy or a beams.

[uncleswagy]

Gaff??? I think maybe getting a gray or a bont are betting around that price even going down to Murphy or beams.

Issacc? Just don't think he can be a top 10 fwd in supercoach

Steven?????? Up and down like I said gray bont or go down to a Murphy or a beams.

youd need an extra 90-100k to go gaff up to bont/gray. if you did wanna have closer to that price id rather take a punt on a hunter of a viney to break out but your probably better off going down to beams or murphy like mentioned or even a swallow type and use the spare coin to upgrade smith

[Glenmaggie]

I agree with most of what people have already said. I think you have gone with too many mids who will not necessarily be top 8, this means you will have to trade them out eventually to be competitive, wasting a trade. Better off to go with a couple more rookies and say a Dangerfied and Treloar/Bont  instead of wines, Gaff and Steven who are unlikely to be top 8. Just my opinion. Good luck!!!!!!

[BigPeen]

Thanks everyone for the comments, might make a few adjustments and look at a few possible replacements

[Money Shot]

Gaff to Swallow
Steven to Danger
Smith to Macrae

And I would look at getting Gawn in as well :)