Round 14 Trades

[Jesty]

Thinking of going Witherden also.
Barrett to Witherden via Hibberd in DEF allows me to take Greenwoods E score.
Then Hannan to Yeo.

[GCSkiwi]

Thinking Scooter + Stewart to Mountford + Roberton, finishes my defence and leaves Newman at D7. Though Gawn is probably a week early back for my liking, if he does ok I might have to flick Newman in oorder to get him in. We'll see.

[SilverLion]

Fisher to Ryan via Lloyd. Covers Fyfe this week. Next week McNiece to Deluca-Cardillo/Witherden/Beech/Cox. Thoughts?

[North Melbournes Finest]

Is 4 Sydney players simply too much?

Kennedy - Hanners - Lloyd - Heeney

I only have the two at the moment, but I also want to bring in Lloyd this week, and the other forward options besides Heeney look terrible. Maybe other option is Toby Greene.

[shaker]

Have had Deluca - Cardillo since RD1 as a floating donut what a week to make a debut ha ha  :P

[North Melbournes Finest]

Hey guys I need help justifying trading out Scott Selwood over Stewart. Here are my pros for trading out Selwood

Pro
- The extra 50k by trading him instead of Stewarts allows me to get Grundy instead of Ryder/Riewoldt
- I get Stewart as my D7 for the rest of the year
- Greenwood's 127 on the field
- I regain DPP between rucks and forwards with Nank/Strnadica

Con
- Makes me burn an extra trade than I intended

Down to 10 trades pre this round. Alternative is trade Stewart straight to Lloyd, sit with Steele on the bench and roll with Bolton on the field. Really need help with this one guys.

Other alternative - Just trade Steele > Goldstein/Grundy/Heeney and play Stewart this week, trade him to Lloyd another week.

[caluuum]

Is 4 Sydney players simply too much?

Kennedy - Hanners - Lloyd - Heeney

I only have the two at the moment, but I also want to bring in Lloyd this week, and the other forward options besides Heeney look terrible. Maybe other option is Toby Greene.

Don't have an issue with it, they have averaged this well so far so why would it be an issue going forward?

[North Melbournes Finest]

Is 4 Sydney players simply too much?

Kennedy - Hanners - Lloyd - Heeney

I only have the two at the moment, but I also want to bring in Lloyd this week, and the other forward options besides Heeney look terrible. Maybe other option is Toby Greene.

Don't have an issue with it, they have averaged this well so far so why would it be an issue going forward?

Thanks mate, I'm always just concerned that if they lose and lose bad, there won't be many points between the 4.

[B.]

Some TRADE advice would be great team!
Made 1 trade so far Williamson- Ryan..... HAVE $234k left to make 1 more if needed (9 for season)

B- Doc, Adams, Laird, Hibberd, Newman, Shaw (Ryan, Shaz)
M- Danger, Pendles, Bont, Sloane, JPK, JSelwood, SSelwood (Fyfe, Mutimer, Cousins)
F- Macrae, Dal, Heeney, Greene, Greenwood, Parsons (Balic, Strndica)

Rucks aren't an issue, Nank is there atm. I am 1 forward short of complete and want Yeo. Want to bring Lloyd in too but he could wait til next week or does he come in this week. Does Fyfe or SSelwood go for Yeo? Or a downgrade to mountford? Or no more trades and have 0 mid bench cover? I CANT DECIDE!

[Ringo]

With Yeo having a high B/e of 119 he can wait as well.

Would be tempted to get get rid of some dead wood to build war chest Mountford, Brown, Witherden nice downgrade options not a lot of cash to be gained but you will have playing rookies on bench.

[tor01doc]

Hey guys I need help justifying trading out Scott Selwood over Stewart. Here are my pros for trading out Selwood

Pro
- The extra 50k by trading him instead of Stewarts allows me to get Grundy instead of Ryder/Riewoldt
- I get Stewart as my D7 for the rest of the year
- Greenwood's 127 on the field
- I regain DPP between rucks and forwards with Nank/Strnadica

Con
- Makes me burn an extra trade than I intended

Down to 10 trades pre this round. Alternative is trade Stewart straight to Lloyd, sit with Steele on the bench and roll with Bolton on the field. Really need help with this one guys.

I would hold Selwood unless you are desperately close in a league game and need to win this week

[North Melbournes Finest]

Hey guys I need help justifying trading out Scott Selwood over Stewart. Here are my pros for trading out Selwood

Pro
- The extra 50k by trading him instead of Stewarts allows me to get Grundy instead of Ryder/Riewoldt
- I get Stewart as my D7 for the rest of the year
- Greenwood's 127 on the field
- I regain DPP between rucks and forwards with Nank/Strnadica

Con
- Makes me burn an extra trade than I intended

Down to 10 trades pre this round. Alternative is trade Stewart straight to Lloyd, sit with Steele on the bench and roll with Bolton on the field. Really need help with this one guys.

I would hold Selwood unless you are desperately close in a league game and need to win this week

Thanks, Ok nah, 2 games on top in my cash league.

Out of the other alternatives would you

Option 1 -
Stewart > Lloyd
Steele > Riewoldt/Ryder/Franklin

Option 2 -
Steele > Goldstein/Grundy/Heeney

Which leaves me with Stewart at D6 - 9 trades and 30k in the bank.

Appreciate any response.