Hall to Zerrett or field Mitch Brown and hold Hall

Started by King_Robbo, July 23, 2016, 08:52:15 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

King_Robbo

I have 3 trades left, $140k in the bank and currently this week I am fielding Greene and M.Brown as my f7/f8 cover in place of Deledio and Hall..

I was pretty keen on holding Hall, but now that he is out for 3 weeks I am thinking of trading him to Zerrett.
This, however would use up pretty much all of my remaining bank and put me down to two trades.

Argument for trading Hall
I am able to get Zerrett who is killing it at the moment, is avoiding the tag week in week out and I dont need to use 2 trades in order to get him in the team
It also immediately improves my team this week, probably picking up 50pts plus over Brown.
Hall is also out for 3 weeks which means its at least half the remaining games that he will miss..

Argument against trading Hall
Puts me down to two trades left with no cash in bank
I may only be trading him to gain an extra 50 pts this week as Lids is most likely back next week and i think that Greene can cover Halls scores. I also dont think that Greene will be too far behind Zerretts scores (maybe 15-20pts per week)
Hall will be a unique when he returns, so if he comes back and smashes out 120s I will move up the overall a fair amount

Would love to know your thoughts peeps

ronl

Take it from me, Mitch Brown isn't very dependable.  Don't get me wrong, he's a decent player, he just doesn't score very well, very often.

shaker

No brainer get Zerrett with no good mids playing at GC think Hall will struggle anyway and they have said he is out for 3 I'm unloading him today

King_Robbo

Quote from: shaker on July 23, 2016, 10:40:25 AM
No brainer get Zerrett with no good mids playing at GC think Hall will struggle anyway and they have said he is out for 3 I'm unloading him today

Yeah I am pretty locked into trading him now..
Also, I am starting to think Buddy might be a better option..
He plays Carlton (h) Freo (a) Port (h) Stk (a) north (a) rich (h)
Against those teams have pretty average backlines. cant see him going below 90 in those games with the next 4 looking particularly juicy