Which Rookies to Field? Post yours here.

[no eye deer]

With all the carnage this week, I thought I'd open a fielded rookies thread. Post yours here and we'll try to work out the best of a bad bunch!

Me, I've got to decide between Collins and Brand in defense and Menapoo and Silvagni forward. Both McViegh and Hall play early, so I can't loophole. :-[

Leaning towards Collins and Silvagni, but not with any confidence.

[crowls]

My choices are limited.   
B: Got Adams, Collins and Joyce in backs.    Playing collins over joyce but not convinced and cannot loophole.
M.  Matho, Mcveigh and Phillips for coverage
F:  No choices playing Naismith and Petracca with Hall and Lids sitting out.    Donut if SMartin late out unless I trade in Clay Smith for Adams before tonights game.     

[RaisyDaisy]

Hall and Lids out for me

Will loophole Collins and Brand, and have to field Sinclair  :-\

Would be chuffed if I can get a 70 out of both

[shaker]

Hall Lids and McVeigh out so Collins or Castagna in the backs
Have Menadue and Petracca to cover in the FWD's but thinking about turning Hall into Greene then see what Petracca gets and keeping Lids this week ..... I don't know just sick of all these outs  :'(

[RaisyDaisy]

Hall Lids and McVeigh out so Collins or Castagna in the backs
Have Menadue and Petracca to cover in the FWD's but thinking about turning Hall into Greene then see what Petracca gets and keeping Lids this week ..... I don't know just sick of all these outs  :'(

Hall to Greene has crossed my mind too

Nice draw for GWS, maintain DPP but Greene is quite the rollercoaster which is why I reckon I might just hold the trade just in case an LTI comes up

[shaker]

Hall Lids and McVeigh out so Collins or Castagna in the backs
Have Menadue and Petracca to cover in the FWD's but thinking about turning Hall into Greene then see what Petracca gets and keeping Lids this week ..... I don't know just sick of all these outs  :'(

Hall to Greene has crossed my mind too

Nice draw for GWS, maintain DPP but Greene is quite the rollercoaster which is why I reckon I might just hold the trade just in case an LTI comes up

Yep thought about that but do I want Menadue's score against the Hawks , could be ugly

[TomK]

Just Silvagni for Hall this week. Will be happy with a 60!

[tor01doc]

2 of Kerridge, Petracca, Joyce or Markov.

Not too hard a decision - one would think.

[Gandalf123]

Mcveigh and Lids out so Collins and Petrac