Cotchin

[GoLions]

Been playing SC since either 07 or 08...don't remember ever having Cotchin :-X

I do have him in BXVs though, and he's killing it there ;D

[js19]

I think you will find that nearly every single person who has played supercoach for the last 4-5 years
has either started with Cotchin or brought him in at some point and been let down. And i do mean literally everyone.

Would love to hear from a long time player who has never had Cotchin in their team at some point..IS THERE ONE WHO WALKS AMONG US!

Why keep touching the burning stove?

To be fair, it's 50/50 this one - your either admitting to being a Cotchin owner of Christmas past, or you're a liar... ;D

[King_Robbo]

Cotchin is a no, unless you want to effectively commit SC suicide
He's too average in everything he does.
He's not great at winning the hard ball
He doesn't dispose of it well
Doesn't kick enough goals
There are so many better players at around his price

[RaisyDaisy]

I think you will find that nearly every single person who has played supercoach for the last 4-5 years
has either started with Cotchin or brought him in at some point and been let down. And i do mean literally everyone.

Would love to hear from a long time player who has never had Cotchin in their team at some point..IS THERE ONE WHO WALKS AMONG US!

Why keep touching the burning stove?

That's me

Never had him, never will

[sammy123]

I think you will find that nearly every single person who has played supercoach for the last 4-5 years
has either started with Cotchin or brought him in at some point and been let down. And i do mean literally everyone.

Would love to hear from a long time player who has never had Cotchin in their team at some point..IS THERE ONE WHO WALKS AMONG US!

Why keep touching the burning stove?

That's me

Never had him, never will

been playing SC since it started back in 05. i have never owned cotchin once. if when i was a noob. the year cotchin finished in top 8 mids i didn't even upgrade to him

[ants]

i had him once! the year he broke out! started him! was my best decision for that year!

[elephants]

Been let down 6 too many times Cotch.

[Judd Magic]

I've had him once or twice.

Don't think its been anymore than twice though.

[quinny88]

Cotchin is a no, unless you want to effectively commit SC suicide
He's too average in everything he does.
He's not great at winning the hard ball
He doesn't dispose of it well
Doesn't kick enough goals
There are so many better players at around his price

Averaging 6th most possessions and 10th most contested possessions in the league so he wins plenty of hard ball but agree there are better options at his price

[JBs-Hawks]

Without ddoing any research whatsoever. I reckon Cotchin plays better in when the tigers are struggling. So depends how you think they will go the rest of the year

[Spite]

Without ddoing any research whatsoever. I reckon Cotchin plays better in when the tigers are struggling. So depends how you think they will go the rest of the year

Jeez in that case, he's a lock for the next 10 years!  ;D

[Mat0369]

That's me

Never had him, never will

I've never had him either.

[Holz]

I think you will find that nearly every single person who has played supercoach for the last 4-5 years
has either started with Cotchin or brought him in at some point and been let down. And i do mean literally everyone.

Would love to hear from a long time player who has never had Cotchin in their team at some point..IS THERE ONE WHO WALKS AMONG US!

Why keep touching the burning stove?

That's me

Never had him, never will

been playing SC since it started back in 05. i have never owned cotchin once. if when i was a noob. the year cotchin finished in top 8 mids i didn't even upgrade to him

only been playing 5 years. The year he was a gun i didnt care about SC so never traded him in. Havent ad him in the last 4 years.

I have had him in DT though. the year he went big. Dont think he has ever disapointed me because i have never picked him up besides his good year and his rookie year.

[tor01doc]

I think you will find that nearly every single person who has played supercoach for the last 4-5 years
has either started with Cotchin or brought him in at some point and been let down. And i do mean literally everyone.

Would love to hear from a long time player who has never had Cotchin in their team at some point..IS THERE ONE WHO WALKS AMONG US!

Why keep touching the burning stove?

Even though I am showere at this, I have won over $1000 and have been playing for quite a few years.

Never ever had Cotchspud in any of my teams.

Partly because if I have a tough choice between two players I tend to pick the one I like to watch more. Eg Started Parker over JPK this year. Love watching Parker.

Cotchin - stoop down stay down mongrel kick get knocked over no support from team mates get up stoop down stay down Etc Etc AND occasionally he kicks it to my most loathed player who ruins the best theme song ever with his own take on it...jerk.

[Big Mac]

Without ddoing any research whatsoever. I reckon Cotchin plays better in when the tigers are struggling. So depends how you think they will go the rest of the year

Plays well when there's no pressure, like most of the side