My SC Team 2010 Please rate, needing advice :)

Started by Adzsta23, March 22, 2010, 11:21:20 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

What do you think :)

1-2/10
3-4/10
5-6/10
7-8/10
9-10/10

Adzsta23

Rate mine plz and ill rate yours back :)

                                                                         
Backline: Enright, Shaw.H, Hodge, Waters                           
                Kennelly, Hunt.J, Ladson                                 
BENCH: Maguire, Trengove


Midfield: Ablett (capt), Michell, Gibbs,
               Trengove, Martin, Selwood
BENCH: Jetta.L(syd), Barlow

Ruck: Sandilands, Cox
BENCH: Lobbe, Bass

Forwards: Riewoldt.N (vice), Franklin, Giansiracusa
                  Tippett, Hall, Zieball, Hitchcock

BENCH: Rockliff, Gumbleton

Jezza

Backline is ok, but I'm unsure of Ladson. You could change Trengove or Nason from Richmond.

Your midfield is solid with 4 stars plus two of the best rookies on the field and the bench is perfect, so no problems there.

Your rucks are super strong, but I think they are too strong so downgrade cox for Clark from Brisbane as he is 100,000 less than Cox, and he'll produce high scores as well. You need to also have a look at your ruck bench as I don't think they are good backups.

Your forward line's ok but I would consider Franklin a risk and maybe get Medhurst for Ziebell and your forward line bench is fine.