Rate my bloody team PLEASE !!!!

[Mark]

Please have a look and comment and rate out of 10 on my team please

BACKS
Goddard
Enright
H.Shaw
Hodge
Gram
Kennelly
Maguire
SUBS
Silvagni - Trengrove

MIDFIELD
Ablett
Swan
Watson
Martin
Barlow
Shuey
SUBS
Banner - Moles

RUCKS
Sandilands
Tippet
SUBS
Warnock - Grimley

FORWARDS
Riewoldt
O'Keefe
B.Harvey
J.Brennan
Hall
Ziebell
Rockcliff
SUBS
Hitchcock - Pods

Please leave comments

[ossie85]

Very solid team, 3 rookie mid a risk, but why not?

But starting 4 rookies overall + Maguire is a bit more risky than I'm willing to do. Perhaps downgrade Swan?

[Mark]

yeah thanks mate

[alman]

Agree with Ossie on the 4 starting rookies and Maguire is a bit much and asking for shower sc scores early days!

Backs - Good choices but lacks in depth (what happens if Maguire doesn't play? as Silvagni and Trengrvoe unlikely). Consider downgrading Shaw and upgrading Trengrove.

Mids - Personally don't like the 3 starting rookie option in the mids, but just my opinion  :) 3 premiums are good choices and so are the rookies!

Rucks - Awesome combo! Good bench.

Forwards - Really like those choices! Considered Brennan myself but dont have room, is going to play more midfield role so should see sc average increase! Usual risks with Rockliff starting. Pods either not elevated or only a couple of matches - suggest look elsewhere for bench.

8/10 - due to 5 under 170k starting and lack of depth in backline  :)

[Mark]

Thanks mate, what about this ??

BACKS
Goddard
Enright
Harbrow
Hodge
Gram
Kennelly
Maguire
SUBS
Silvagni - Waters

MIDFIELD
Ablett
Swan
Watson
Martin
Barlow
Shuey
SUBS
Banner - Moles

RUCKS
Sandilands
Tippet
SUBS
Warnock - Grimley

FORWARDS
Riewoldt
O'Keefe
B.Harvey
J.Brennan
Hall
Ziebell
Rockcliff
SUBS
Hitchcock - Pods

[alman]

Better  :) I have Waters starting and Maguire on bench (are good coverage for eachother!).

Dont like Gilbee as is no reason he will increase his average, consider Harbrow at that price..

[Mark]

Thanks mate, good luck

[Mark]

please comment guys

[Marty14]

get rid of barlow and get Keiren Jack a way better player

[Mark]

CANT GET $$ MATE

[Prospector_1]

get rid of barlow and get Keiren Jack a way better player

Except he's out suspended.

[Mark]

any other suggestions. Thanks guys