Who to bench?

Started by MC, August 16, 2015, 09:42:49 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

MC

Leaning towards benching Houli for Birchall's 98. What do you guys think?

Jay

I'd bench Rance. Not sure if he'll be able to find the pill much in the defensive 50 - they'll destroy Gold Coast.

_wato

#2
Quote from: Jayman on August 16, 2015, 09:57:34 AM
I'd bench Rance. Not sure if he'll be able to find the pill much in the defensive 50 - they'll destroy Gold Coast.

Disagree, they won't destroy GC and he'll play on Tom Lynch whom they'll look to everytime before delivering to Dixon (plenty of
opportunity imo) and will have his work cut out too because Lynch is in red hot form. In saying that, I would also bench Rance because he could as much towel him and score 130+ or not so much like last week against Tex and score 60 or similiar. Houli should carve up I'm thinking.

enzedder

Rance but it's risky...I'd be inclined to play all of them.

MC

Quote from: enzedder on August 16, 2015, 10:15:35 AM
Rance but it's risky...I'd be inclined to play all of them.


I'm going for overall (aiming top 100) so don't think I can pass up a 98 from a defender. The risk is benching the wrong bloke!
Looking likely to be Rance now from the poll  :-\

PICCOLLO

definitely use the loop but it really is a toss up

RaisyDaisy

I'd go with Rance, simply because he has the largest deviation of the 3

Could come out and go 120+, but could come out with a 60 too

I think (and hope) Houli is safe for a 80-100 score, and Picken just has to be played based on his year

enzedder

Quote from: MC on August 16, 2015, 10:54:36 AM
Quote from: enzedder on August 16, 2015, 10:15:35 AM
Rance but it's risky...I'd be inclined to play all of them.


I'm going for overall (aiming top 100) so don't think I can pass up a 98 from a defender. The risk is benching the wrong bloke!
Looking likely to be Rance now from the poll  :-\
Realise that but wouldn't be surprised if they all go 100+.... whoever you loophole could burn. Voted Rance.

GoLions

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on August 16, 2015, 11:16:53 AM
I'd go with Rance, simply because he has the largest deviation of the 3

Could come out and go 120+, but could come out with a 60 too

I think (and hope) Houli is safe for a 80-100 score, and Picken just has to be played based on his year
I sort of disagree with that logic. I would bench the one most likely to score less than 98. If you think Houli is good for an 80-100 score, I'd bench him 100%

Making the assumption that you'd usually play these two over Birchall btw.

RaisyDaisy

Of course Picken was the right choice this week lol

RaisyDaisy

And of course once I post that he has a good last qtr lol

Turns out it was a mute point. They all scored very similarly