Quick vote plz..

[Mark]

Trading McLean to a better pic..
Who do you think will score better and take into account SC finals as on top of league..

[hawkboy80]

goddard for consistency ... i think  :o

[GCSkiwi]

Lets just put up their finals opponents:

Goddard: GWS, Crows, Suns, Tigers

Boomer: Dees, Saints, Freo, Dogs

Bartel: Swans, Hawks, Saints, Pies

Buddy: Cats, Pies, GWS, Saints

Boomer I just think is too inconsistent, he'll probably get a huge score in there but not worth having over the 4 games.
Bartel has a tougher draw than either Goddard or Buddy but I think that might actually work for him, if he's playing in the guts it could mean a bit of contested ball. Sydney he's been weaker against in the past but the others he scores well against, and he steps up in big games.

Goddard and Buddy have similar draws, but in looking at their history against opponent it actually looks like Goddard dominates his finals opponents. Buddy will either go big or not really rate, so I agree with the call that Goddard is probably a more consistent option...

I think Bartel just because he's a bit fresher at this stage, second choice would be Goddard, Buddy for the player who will either win or lose you match ups on his own boot...

[Mark]

goddard for consistency ... i think  :o

Cheers mate

Lets just put up their finals opponents:

Goddard: GWS, Crows, Suns, Tigers

Boomer: Dees, Saints, Freo, Dogs

Bartel: Swans, Hawks, Saints, Pies

Buddy: Cats, Pies, GWS, Saints

Boomer I just think is too inconsistent, he'll probably get a huge score in there but not worth having over the 4 games.
Bartel has a tougher draw than either Goddard or Buddy but I think that might actually work for him, if he's playing in the guts it could mean a bit of contested ball. Sydney he's been weaker against in the past but the others he scores well against, and he steps up in big games.

Goddard and Buddy have similar draws, but in looking at their history against opponent it actually looks like Goddard dominates his finals opponents. Buddy will either go big or not really rate, so I agree with the call that Goddard is probably a more consistent option...

I think Bartel just because he's a bit fresher at this stage, second choice would be Goddard, Buddy for the player who will either win or lose you match ups on his own boot...

Thanks so much , great info and much help

[Mark]

Im really shocked Bartel is so far ahead of Goddard to be honest..

[Bully]

Im really shocked Bartel is so far ahead of Goddard to be honest..

It's a coin toss but I voted Bartel given he has the fresher legs. Looking at Goddard's scoring last year he dropped off significantly as the season progressed, only 2 tons in his last 8 games.

[GCSkiwi]

Im really shocked Bartel is so far ahead of Goddard to be honest..

It's a coin toss but I voted Bartel given he has the fresher legs. Looking at Goddard's scoring last year he dropped off significantly as the season progressed, only 2 tons in his last 8 games.

Yep exactly the same with me, Bartel or Goddard would be good options but I put up Bartel in the poll due to him being fresher :)

[Grazz]

Bartel i reckon, Jimmy will give his all to lift the Cats out of the mess their in.

[Mark]

Well after reading votes and comments from the big 3 on this site Bartel it is

[shaker]

Buddy has been pretty quite so far think he will be coming good by then

[Grazz]

Buddy has been pretty quite so far think he will be coming good by then

Would you like me to say how quiet he's been, i can if you want, ive had a front row seat.  :(
C'mon Buddy fire up and make an old man happy.