Shiel the real deal??

[PICCOLLO]

What we've seen is what you'll get.  A bit like Treloar, he'll go high and he'll go low and probably average out at around 105-110.  So many players (coniglio, smith) who go big some weeks and not others.  Consistency is better found elsewhere.

[Gigantor]

What we've seen is what you'll get.  A bit like Treloar, he'll go high and he'll go low and probably average out at around 105-110.  So many players (coniglio, smith) who go big some weeks and not others.  Consistency is better found elsewhere.

Who? Jpk, Sloane, Jelwood?  Fyfe and Pendles only proven consistent super premos at the moment

[Southstorm]

What we've seen is what you'll get.  A bit like Treloar, he'll go high and he'll go low and probably average out at around 105-110.  So many players (coniglio, smith) who go big some weeks and not others.  Consistency is better found elsewhere.

I'll take 105-110 for an M8 and I'll take an M8 for $500k any day.

[H1bb3i2d]

What we've seen is what you'll get.  A bit like Treloar, he'll go high and he'll go low and probably average out at around 105-110.  So many players (coniglio, smith) who go big some weeks and not others.  Consistency is better found elsewhere.

I'll take 105-110 for an M8 and I'll take an M8 for $500k any day.

For $20k more you could buy a Sloane who should still be a 110+ mid.

[Southstorm]

What we've seen is what you'll get.  A bit like Treloar, he'll go high and he'll go low and probably average out at around 105-110.  So many players (coniglio, smith) who go big some weeks and not others.  Consistency is better found elsewhere.

I'll take 105-110 for an M8 and I'll take an M8 for $500k any day.

For $20k more you could buy a Sloane who should still be a 110+ mid.

When I brought Shiel in, Sloane was well over $600k and at that stage not looking like slowing down. More than happy to have both though.

[elephants]

What we've seen is what you'll get.  A bit like Treloar, he'll go high and he'll go low and probably average out at around 105-110.  So many players (coniglio, smith) who go big some weeks and not others.  Consistency is better found elsewhere.

I'll take 105-110 for an M8 and I'll take an M8 for $500k any day.

For $20k more you could buy a Sloane who should still be a 110+ mid.

When I brought Shiel in, Sloane was well over $600k and at that stage not looking like slowing down. More than happy to have both though.

Did the opposite, brought in Sloane for over 600k for a lovely pair of 60s :)

[Blues Blues Blues]

What we've seen is what you'll get.  A bit like Treloar, he'll go high and he'll go low and probably average out at around 105-110.  So many players (coniglio, smith) who go big some weeks and not others.  Consistency is better found elsewhere.

I'll take 105-110 for an M8 and I'll take an M8 for $500k any day.

For $20k more you could buy a Sloane who should still be a 110+ mid.

When I brought Shiel in, Sloane was well over $600k and at that stage not looking like slowing down. More than happy to have both though.

Did the opposite, brought in Sloane for over 600k for a lovely pair of 60s :)

Me too elephantitis

[PICCOLLO]

What we've seen is what you'll get.  A bit like Treloar, he'll go high and he'll go low and probably average out at around 105-110.  So many players (coniglio, smith) who go big some weeks and not others.  Consistency is better found elsewhere.

Who? Jpk, Sloane, Jelwood?  Fyfe and Pendles only proven consistent super premos at the moment

Very true.  There are really only 2-3 super premos going around. (Gaz, Fyfe, Pendles)
As far as elite mids go, JPK, Sloane, Selwood should all be around 115ppg by years end.

Selwood et al. often have periods of scoring 80ish for a few but the 150s make up for it.  Being in a top 8 side that's winning games helps.
IMHO, Selwood and Sloane in 1-2 weeks will be better options and score more than Shiel.

[netterzzzz]

Yes? No?

got lewis and looking to trade.. ranked 600th so dont really want to risk 550k on the bench for 2 weeks.

Is D.Shiel worth it ? he seems to be getting a lot of the pill and racking up huge points. but that one week of 60 odd scares me..

let me know

[ronl]

Reckon the coach may have had a word or two with him after that 60.  Could have discussed something called "attitude''.

[meow meow]

Reckon the coach may have had a word or two with him after that 60.  Could have discussed something called "attitude''.

Reckon it had more to do with something called "being tagged".

[The_Captain]

Reckon the coach may have had a word or two with him after that 60.  Could have discussed something called "attitude''.

Reckon it had more to do with something called "being tagged".

I heard it was something to do with "being gagged"

[tkringle]

Absolute jet. backing him to push through the tough games and go a 115 average by end of year.