Lonie or Tarrant?

[Hazza09]

Am trading one of these 2 for Dale this week but not sure who is the best one to trade.

Lonie had a B/E of 95 but has a reasonable price difference to Tarrant if i trade him (70k)

Im hoping Tarrants game last week was a one off but i find him better bench coverage than Lonie.

If i trade Tarrant as opposed to Lonie i will have 280k which will allow me to upgrade a rookie to a decent prem.

I guess its just the 70k price difference that is making it difficult to decide.

Cheers

[kilbluff1985]

Hansen back and fit is impacting Taz imo

[muggle25]

If you hold Lonie, you will have to hold him through the byes.  with that 3 in his rolling average it's going to effect his price massively.  That said, he has great job security and if he can sit on your bench scoring 50-80 each week - no harm done.

Good reasons both to hold and trade with Lonie. 

Tarrant has peaked for the time being - good time for a cash grab, may loose a little cash this week, job security not as good as Lonie's.  Role may be switched between def/fwd and this could affect his scoring.

I think I would keep Lonie and trade Tarrant.  And I think I've just talked myself into trading Tarrant and keeping Salem (although I am worried about whether he will be back for the byes).

[jfitty]

Tarrant has peaked for the time being - good time for a cash grab, may loose a little cash this week, job security not as good as Lonie's.  Role may be switched between def/fwd and this could affect his scoring.

I don't think this is the case. The only guy who can affect Tarrant's job security is Nathan Grima, who is still around a month away. Arguably Joel Tippett too, but I don't think he posses a big threat.

The addition of Hansen may be hampering Tarrant's scoring potential, but Hansen isn't going to play a traditional key defender roll. He's the 'extra man' back there taking intercept marks. I can't see Tarrant moving forward with Waite, Petrie and Brown already there, and I certainly wouldn't want Hansen standing a key forward either!

However, I'm deciding between these 2 on who to trade as well. Leaning towards Lonie though, as Tarrant technically isn't a rookie, and has shown he can score big. Him and Clark rotating through F6 for a few weeks looks good to me.

[muggle25]

What's your take on Dumont jfitty?  Will he stay in the team through the byes do you think?

[Hazza09]

The thing with Lonie is if you dont trade him this week then you have to keep him till the bye rounds.
I dont like the fact that i also will be relying on Lonie and Lambert as my fwd emergencies.

Trading Tarrant would prove to be a much better cash gain but im just hoping if i go Lonie that extra 70k doesnt come back to bite me.

[J Pot]

Tarrant has a round 13 bye. It's tempting to trade him out, but he could be a vital player to hold through the first 2 bye rounds, particularly round 12. I'm tempted to trade him too, but I think he's a hold for now.

[Grufflez]

Tarrant has a round 13 bye. It's tempting to trade him out, but he could be a vital player to hold through the first 2 bye rounds, particularly round 12. I'm tempted to trade him too, but I think he's a hold for now.

+1

[tor01doc]

Tarrant has a round 13 bye. It's tempting to trade him out, but he could be a vital player to hold through the first 2 bye rounds, particularly round 12. I'm tempted to trade him too, but I think he's a hold for now.

+1

After a bit more thought, bye consideration and a degree of confidence in Tarrant, I will hold him and look at Heeney out instead.

Bad bye, still out and high BE.

[Hazza09]

Lonie it is!!  :-\