Goodwin vs Broughton vs Duffield

[DanielRich]

With Fisher now out for 6 weeks, i need a premium defender to cover, who should i get between Goodwin, Broughton and Duffield?

[Prospector_1]

To cover, or to replace?

[Cicjose]

my guess is replace

[Prospector_1]

Do we want Fisher back later - ie, make money between now and then, or will we go for a different player with similar ability and potential?

[Big Lance]

Goodwin or Duffeild.

[Prospector_1]

So not Broughton? Why not?

[CFC 1979]

lock Broughton away

kills fisher in scoring