Rate my Team please.

[pduthieau]

Looking for any hints people might be able give me.

Mason Cox is in simply for Captains Loophole at the moment.

[Jacko]

How much $ left?

[swans15]

Way too many risky picks in there. Would definately go Bird>Swan and maybe dowgrade Cameron to rookie and upgrade Josh Thomas.

[pduthieau]

Sorry, should have mentioned that - $11,900. Will update original post as well.

[greco272]

The first thing i will say about this team is there is way to many mid price players that arn't proven SC scores.

For example

Langdon - Was good last year but at 380k he will have to average high 85+ to be a keeper. There are better options (Geary, MacMillian, Whitecross)

Hodge - May be rested during the year, maybe get Gibson if you want a hawks player, hibbard, smith or shaw look like better options for the same price.

Mids are pretty good, i feel like pendalbury is a must have!

Rucks - Great...!!

Fwds - Bird, Cameron & Thomas arn't proven SC scores, there are much better options in the price range. Try to avoid picking big FWDs as they don't get alot of opportunity and need to kick big bags to score well. Replace Bird with a premium like Bartel, Martin, Goddard or Grey. Zorko and Bannell are good picks you should stick with them.

This team does have some good picks, but just needs a few changes, try and stay away from those mid range players, they just don't end up going anywhere during the season and you will find yourself behind the 8 ball early on!

Hopefully this helps, and remember its just my view on things so i could be wrong :) happy supercoaching!

[aussied]

playing around with getting zorko into my team, i think he will be the real bread winner out of such a deep midfield.   dont see him copping the tag before beams, rich, rocky.            if not christo would be next.       

im gonna do some research on C.pearce to see if hes worth it, thinking he might have good Job security and is worth that price tag.

i would downgrade either rocky to a selwood or fyfe to a priddis / kennedy then upgrade bird to a bartel / martin. no josh thomas and jcameron.  and bring in hogan.

[pduthieau]

Ok, latest version:



Currently not sure on:

Lumumba v Kolodjashnij (or should I swap Taylor for Kolodjashnij and put another Rookie in at D4?)

Would like to try and fit another Premium Mid in, but I do have 2 Premium Mids in the Forward line.

Not 100% on Cameron atm - would like to keep him in (as he's a relative), but would I be better with Hogan?

Current balance is $39,900

[Holden the ball]

downgrade sheridan to 130 - 140 k rookie then look to upgrade

[Holden the ball]

and also cameron to hogan would find you some cash