Mike Sheehan's Top 50: The best players of the past 25 years

[LF]

Thought this was interesting and would generate some conversation on here as well

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/mike-sheahans-top-50-the-best-players-of-the-past-25-years/story-fnp04d70-1227272733389

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/mikes-top-50

This is the top 10



Then there's this,will be a live chat tomorrow

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/jon-anderson-questions-mike-sheahans-top-50-and-answers-your-burning-questions/story-fni5f22o-1227273715574

Jon Anderson questions Mike Sheahan’s Top 50 and answers your burning questions

[SydneyRox]

Plugger undervalued IMO

Matera, Judd too high

[LF]

Buckley at 16 is too high

[nrich102]

Simon Black and Jono Brown are way to far down the list.

Also missing some Tom Rockliff  :P

[RaisyDaisy]

Same old every year. Just one person with their opinion yet so many people get fired up over it lol it's quite funny

Definitely some pics that I don't agree with, but that's the beauty of opinions

[Ringo]

If we all agreed with Mike Sheehan the world would be an unhappy place.

Find it odd with Dunstall at 4 and Johnno Brown at 34. Would have thought Brown would be at the very least close to Dunstall.

Just Personal but I would also have Simon Black ahead of Voss as I think Black was the better all round player.

Also Think Diesel Williams and Judd are a little high.

But as I said will be interesting arguments.

[Big Mac]

Really need to watch some old footy games some time - Would be good to see just how good Carey really was

[Jroo]

Where the flower is Richo

[RaisyDaisy]

Where the flower is Richo

Read the article - he pretty much dedicated the first half of it to him :)

[The_Captain]

Piss awf Carey. Ablett any day!! 

[Jroo]

Where the flower is Richo

Read the article - he pretty much dedicated the first half of it to him :)

Oh cheers, will do.
Haha only looked at the list didn't read the article, ain't nobody got time for that  :P

[truBLUE]

Piss awf Carey. Ablett any day!! 



+1 have to agree loved watching snr ,best  carey moment i remember was carey, stevens /archer going at it after the stevo's wife affair hahaha classic :)

[The_Captain]

Piss awf Carey. Ablett any day!! 



+1 have to agree loved watching snr ,best  carey moment i remember was carey, stevens /archer going at it after the stevo's wife affair hahaha classic :)

Hahaha that's all I remember! Glen archer wanting his head off his shoulder!

[JBs-Hawks]

If we all agreed with Mike Sheehan the world would be an unhappy place.

Find it odd with Dunstall at 4 and Johnno Brown at 34. Would have thought Brown would be at the very least close to Dunstall.

Just Personal but I would also have Simon Black ahead of Voss as I think Black was the better all round player.

Also Think Diesel Williams and Judd are a little high.

But as I said will be interesting arguments.

How should Brown be close to Dunstall?

[Ringo]

Just think they both deserve to be in Top 10 JB because of their performances over time.  My Beef is 34 imo is way too low for Brown.

Both played a similar amount of games - Dunstall was a more prolific goal kicker though but Hawthorn were a top team right through whereas Brisbane were on the slide for most of Browns Career.

Both were twice All Australian reps.

Brown 3 times winner of the most courageous player award.

Both were inspirational Captains and leaders for their club.