First go at sc

[Mrdiggy]

First time on super coach, got some ideas from previous threads and filled in the rest...
Any suggestions or tips on my first go would be great. Cheers

H Shaw J Newnes D Rampe R Henderson C Byrne H Goddard - D Viojo-Rainbow N Newman

G Ablett N Fyfe J Selwood B Gibbs P Dangerfield N Van Berlo N Cockatoo N Freeman - J Steele D Mckenzie A Saad

S Jacobs P Ryder - M Cox

B Goddard D Martin D Swan L Henderson T Menzel J Hogan C Daniel K Lambert

$4, 600 left

[hawkboy80]

not a bad start, maybe try & strengthen the backline a bit tho

[My Chumps]

Not bad from a first timer dude!

Defence could do with some work. I guess Rampe could improve with Malceski's departure but I really think an 80 average is the best we can expect from him, and at that price he's really not worth it. I'd suggest checking out Lumumba instead who's been killing it this pre-season by all reports. Could also check out Shane Savage, Elliot Yeo or Jack Grimes for guys around that price that should improve.

Mids are good, pretty unique but that's all g.

Rucks are fine. Ryder's a seriously unique selection! I'm personally steering clear of expensive rucks due to the new scoring system for hitouts but that's just a personal thing.

Forwards could do with some work. Goddard, Martin and Swan are all sound picks, but Henderson is an average selection. Really can't see him upping his average enough to be worth it. I'd look at Tommy Mitchell instead for someone else around that price. Troy Menzel could work to but maybe look elsewhere.

Good luck man, hope I've helped!

[AaronKirk]

First time on super coach, got some ideas from previous threads and filled in the rest...
Any suggestions or tips on my first go would be great. Cheers

H Shaw J Newnes D Rampe R Henderson C Byrne H Goddard - D Viojo-Rainbow N Newman

G Ablett N Fyfe J Selwood B Gibbs P Dangerfield N Van Berlo N Cockatoo N Freeman - J Steele D Mckenzie A Saad

S Jacobs P Ryder - M Cox

B Goddard D Martin D Swan L Henderson T Menzel J Hogan C Daniel K Lambert

$4, 600 left

Very weak defence. Lot of work needs to be done there

Gibbs and Danger POD's but risky midfield picks. IMO drop one to a rookie and maybe keep the other as a POD.

Get rid of Ryder. Will most likely play most of his time forward with Lobbe as the number one ruck choice at Port Adelaide.

Henderson and Menzel are not great picks. Menzel to M.Clark and Henderson to Bellchambers to give ruck cover or a premo opition.