Main Menu

British XV's MVP Award

Started by Ringo, August 26, 2014, 08:19:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

JBs-Hawks

Beams,  SJ and Sidey? :P[move][/move]

Spite

Quote from: Ringo on August 27, 2014, 09:31:09 AM
Happy too and if any other coaches wish to know there top 3 plese post in this thraed and I will oblige.

David Zaharakis and Luke Parker both on 10
Levi Greenwood 8

Sorry we don't have zaharakis, who is that one meant to be? Thanks Ringo!

Rusty00

Great job with the count Ringo.

Can I have the Werewolves Top 3 as well. Cheers

Ringo

Gee Spite Having fun with Hedgehogs but here is correct:

Hedgehogs
10 Luke Parker
8 Levi Greenwood
6 Jarrad McVeigh, Dustin Martin, Brent Stanton

Liverpool Rams
16 Adam Treloar
15 Dyson Heppell
9 Brent Harvey

Crosby Cruisers
17 Nathan Jones
12 Travis Boak
9 Jack Redden

Huddersfield Hawks
20 Dayne Beams
18 Steve Johnson
9 Steele Sidebottom
so spot on JB.

Nige

Oh wow, Treloar polled better than Heppell by a vote.

Dyson's still happy he won the B&F though.  :P


LF

Can you post Hoods as well please Ringo

Ringo

Hoods:

14 Jackson Macrae
12 Scott Pendlebury
10 Daniel Hannebury
Shame Hanners spent so much time on the sidelines.

LF

Quote from: Ringo on August 27, 2014, 08:14:18 PM
Hoods:

14 Jackson Macrae
12 Scott Pendlebury
10 Daniel Hannebury
Shame Hanners spent so much time on the sidelines.

Thankyou
Yes he probably would have beaten Pendles in the B&F if he had played the whole season

JBs-Hawks

Crazy that Macrae beat Pendles but then again the MVP doesnt reward consistency just big scores.

LF

Quote from: JBs-Hawks on August 27, 2014, 08:19:11 PM
Crazy that Macrae beat Pendles but then again the MVP doesnt reward consistency just big scores.

Well for this year I used highest scorer of the week for B&F and Pendles won easy Gray 2nd,Macrae 3rd and Hanners 4th
Macrae threw up a couple of stinkers and got no votes a few weeks
Next season I`m going to come up with a different way of doing it I think

Ringo

MVP is really a hit and miss similar to Brownlow in that votes are awarded per game and depends on the opposition as well.

AS an example any playing the Werewolves would have been disadvantaged until Gazz was injured,  Gazz polled 3 votes in 9 of the seventeen rounds.

Sydney_Rox

Quote from: luvfooty on August 27, 2014, 08:23:34 PM
Quote from: JBs-Hawks on August 27, 2014, 08:19:11 PM
Crazy that Macrae beat Pendles but then again the MVP doesnt reward consistency just big scores.

Well for this year I used highest scorer of the week for B&F and Pendles won easy Gray 2nd,Macrae 3rd and Hanners 4th
Macrae threw up a couple of stinkers and got no votes a few weeks
Next season I`m going to come up with a different way of doing it I think

When I do my scoring I judge the mids harsher. A def score of 120 would get the 3 votes in front of a mid 130 the way I work it


Spite

Wow hedgehogs won most things this year but all barely polled any votes! Seems a little strange :P

LF

Quote from: Sydney_Rox on August 27, 2014, 10:44:21 PM
Quote from: luvfooty on August 27, 2014, 08:23:34 PM
Quote from: JBs-Hawks on August 27, 2014, 08:19:11 PM
Crazy that Macrae beat Pendles but then again the MVP doesnt reward consistency just big scores.

Well for this year I used highest scorer of the week for B&F and Pendles won easy Gray 2nd,Macrae 3rd and Hanners 4th
Macrae threw up a couple of stinkers and got no votes a few weeks
Next season I`m going to come up with a different way of doing it I think

When I do my scoring I judge the mids harsher. A def score of 120 would get the 3 votes in front of a mid 130 the way I work it

Thing is probably wouldn't change the result much as the mids scored over 130 most weeks haha

Ringo

Quote from: Spite on August 27, 2014, 11:02:47 PM
Wow hedgehogs won most things this year but all barely polled any votes! Seems a little strange :P
One of the disadvantages as happens in Brownlow in having a team of consistent performers but not an outstanding player such as an Ablett.  Although you finished on Top of the ladder the consistency of players effected voting. You had 12 players polling votes compared to a lot of other teams with 10 or less.