Goddard vs Ebert

Started by jmoynihan9, August 08, 2014, 06:58:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

jmoynihan9

Have to pick one to trade out. Both down on form but both have good records against respective opponents.
Goddard has averaged 118.75 since 2009 against the Tigers, with scores of 110(2012), 131(2013), 117(2013) and 114(2014) since 2012. Also averages 116.2 at the G' in the past 2 years, with scores of 121, 104, 131, 92, 94, 122 and 117 in 2013 and 110, 114 and 157 this year. However Goddard extremely low on form with a 3 round average of 72.3 and 5 round of 90.
Ebert has averaged 124.33 against Sydney since 2012, with scores of 123(2012), 114(2013) and 136(2014) in that time period. He has averaged 109.6 this year at Adelaide oval, with scores of 127, 152, 112, 109, 115, 110, 84, 98, 87 and 102. Good stats but the fact in the past 2 months he has only gone over 100 once at Adelaide Oval with an average of 92.75. He is coming off a 3 round average of 86.7 and a 5 round average of 89 so another concern.

Both good records but down on form! Opinions please people!

Just for some context my team goes:

DEF: Bartel, McVeigh, Swallow, Hanley, Simpson, Mitchell    Langford, Thompson
MID: Rockliff, Johnson, Pendlebury, Beams, Heppel, Barlow, Goddard, Ebert    Lloyd, Shenton
RUC: Martin, Jacobs    Brown, Currie
FOR: Martin, Parker, Dangerfield, Gray, McGlynn, Dahlhaus    McGovern, Johnson
Cash: 90,099k

First trade will be Shenton to a throwaway M10 most likely Dom Barry, then obviously Ebert or Goddard to a premo mid. Thinking J Kennedy, but Sidebottom and Priddis tempting.

If anyone has any more ideas opinions are welcome! The Shenton to Barry trade gives me 261,319k to upgrade Ebert or Goddard to whoever. Trading both would give me 1,063,603k to spend on two premo mids which is scraping the barrel really.

Cheers in advance!