My Supercoach, Perfect 10!

Started by Longy88, March 11, 2010, 11:02:20 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Please rate my team out of 10 (given its above 5)

6/10
8 (36.4%)
7/10
5 (22.7%)
8/10
7 (31.8%)
9/10
2 (9.1%)
10/10
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 5

Longy88

Could be the first perfect 10! Please add any comments if you think otherwise!

Backs: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Macdonald, Gram, Malceski, Waters
Bench: Maguire, Silvagni

Mids: Selwood, Mitchell, Gibbs, Boak, Martin, Barlow
Bench: Banner, Moles

Rucks: Sandilands, Hille
Bench: Currie, Trengove

Forwards: Riewoldt, ROK, Pavlich, Gia, Tippet, Danger, Rockliff
Bench: Hitchcock, Dennis-Lane

Only thing i can do is Out: ROK, Mitchell, Tippet(fwd), Hille
IN: Franklin, Higgins, Vince, Tippet(ruc)

Like the team with ROK though!

cmgb84

a sc team without ablett is never a 10

Longy88

Alright, fair point. But its more than a 6 or 7 like some have voted!

alman

My biggest problem is that you have all of Waters, Martin, Barlow and Rockliff in your starting side. Consider upgrading TDL to Ballantyne or Westhoff.

Backs strong and love that you have both Gram and Macdonald - could be your x-factor.

Mids - no complaints but would consider stronger captain: GAJ, Dal or Swan.

Rucks - great and hope Hille doesn't break down on you. There are better bench options in Warnock, Skipper, Roughhead.

Forwards - strong, only weakpoint as mentioned before is Rockliff starting and no back up available as TDL probably won't play till later in the season as Rohan will get a birth before him and Hitch not elevated (although deserves to be)..

8/10 as need better captain and consider not starting Rockliff  :)

hubbaup

No Ablett = No 10 i give it an 8 downgrade Macdonald to say a Ladson and upgrade Boak to Ablett if you can afford that and maybe swap Danger for Ballentyne

Wastelander


Wastelander

#6
I'd probably downgrade Macdonald to L. Greenwood as your backline is strong enough.
And swap Danger for Warren as you have a pretty solid forward aswell.
The mid is your weak point, IMO. That way you could dump the extra coin into fixing up the mid to make it a bit sronger.


Longy88

Seriously, who cares? Teams change!

tomsully

his just wanting feedback on his team. fair go you loser resch. not a bad team mate. rate myne

supercoachheroes

wtf resch are you joking? there is thousand of posts and he cant do 4?

lowedown11

common guys dun get ur knickers in a knot....if thats ur biggest problem in life ur goin pretty well!!!!