RATE OR DIE!

Started by nexus6, March 11, 2010, 02:29:16 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

nexus6

Goddard, Goodwin, Enright, Gram, Malceski, Hunt, Waters
[Maguire, Silvagni]

Ablett, Goodes, Boyd, Armitage, Martin, Barlow
[Shuey, Banner]

Petrie, Tippett
[Roughead, Lobbe]

Harvey, Akermanis, S Johnson, Gray, Hall, Dangerfield, Mayne
[Rockliff, Podisadly]

hawk_88

Generally it is a good idea to spend some time commenting on other sides before asking people to rate yours, especially with a thread titled "RATE OR DIE!".

People will tend to be more willing to offer advice and help if you do the same for others.

nexus6

....you must be too old..or too young, to remember skate or die!

hawk_88

Didn't get the reference straight away. Know the game despite is coming out a year before my birth. That being said, what I said still applies.

MattJN

I've got a fever...

And the only prescription?

Is more cowbell!!!!

Big_Cox14

Backline looks fine.
Midfield - good to see Ablett there. Midfield also looks fine.
Rucks - Petrie's a good player but he is suspended for the first couple of rounds. Not sure how likely Roughie or Lobbe will play round 1. You could get a doughnut if this isn't fixed.
Forwards - Not sure about the choice of Stevie J. He has recently had problems with a hip injury.

Overall, your side is fairly decent. Potential weaknesses in the rucks & forward line though which I've already highlighted. 8/10.

Ricko

great looking team, stevie J would be my only concern

8.5 / 10

nexus6

cheers guys, wasnt onto the petrie suspension, might swap him out for H Mac

stevie j.....i just like him too much! but he isnt locked