How can Supercoach Sub Fiasco be fixed 2015

[Spite]

So no one has thought about a best 20 playing each week? Allows for two sub scores. Maybe add another forward and defender and make it a best 22 (24 on field) which should eliminate some sub scores.
There would be some obvious strategies to try and exploit this (loading mids) but you'd have less cash generation.

Especially if you removed a bench spot in each position.

6 forwards, 6 backs, 2 rucks, 8 mids with one bench spot per possie.

Top 18/20 count.

Thoughts?

[kilbluff1985]

more forward spots? forward rookies are most prone to green vests

i just think the easiest and fairest way is to receive the players average if they get the green vest

[Pokerface]

more forward spots? forward rookies are most prone to green vests

i just think the easiest and fairest way is to receive the players average if they get the green vest

This isn't fair or easy at all. Would that be their unsubbed average? What do you do with those who are first gamers? And if you see someone has a green vest after final teams, you can bring them in knowing exactly what score they'll get. This is not good - especially if its the last match of the round and a potential league result is on the line.

There is nothing wrong with what we have. Its part of the game and you select accordingly. Whether or not we should have rolling lockouts if(?) people can't access the internet after vests are announced is a different discussion.

[Rusty00]

I say the afl goes back to split round in say round 11 and have one supercoach round over 2 weeks .

That would make way too much sense

Players association are the ones pushing for weeks off during the season. No way they would go back to only 1 week off.

[GoLions]

I say the afl goes back to split round in say round 11 and have one supercoach round over 2 weeks .

That would make way too much sense

Players association are the ones pushing for weeks off during the season. No way they would go back to only 1 week off.

2 split rounds would be ideal

[joshua98]

Similar to above however, set-up is the same with 22 on field and a squad of 30, however, best 21 players complete your score. Means a green vest or red vest wouldn't make a huge difference. This also mirrors the concept of the AFL with 21 starting players

[RaisyDaisy]

Yeah I agree with what some of the guys before me have said

Field X amount of players, but Top X amount scores count

Say 22 are fielded as is, but only 21 count

No more than 1 though