Goddard v Murphy v Jelwood

[DTCoach]

would it be clever or a waste to trade murphy to goddard in RDT and net 100k for other upgrades next week?

Who will be the better scorer. I have more confidence in goddard but murphy has shown he can pump out big scores, just the potential for 80s with him worries me.

Could also wait a week and probably get J Selwood at about the same as Goddard is now but is he a better option than goddard?

could also do polec to goddard for 40k (or to selwood in a week for similar).

or leave it, but goddard at 450k is so damn cheap!

[pommyadam]

Jelwood BE = 135
Murphy BE = 145
Goddard BE = 47
Polec BE = 68

would personally wait a week (or two) if you're getting Jelwood (who's Crowley going to this week?)
it depends on the upgrades you'll be making next week too

would take Goddard over Murphy personally (Goddard's averaging 111 without his injured game)
but this is the ideal week if you are jumping on BJ, maybe drop Polec instead (those inconsistent mid rooks)

[DTCoach]

yeah I'm thinking ill keep murphy and ditch polec instead, gives me a 'completed' midfield keeping him over polec (can be stronger but Ablett, rocky, beams, pendles, swan, cotchin, murphy, selwood/goddard

other option would be to go murphy/polec to goddad this week and the other to selwood next week if nothing else comes up. would be 'ok' with byes giving me 18 playing without trading but its a matter of if murphy to either of those is too sideways since murph has pimped out 2 140s and a 120 in the last 4!

most other trades i want to do fwd/back involve round 10 players who will also drop this week (maybe hanley or even jeansch who is obviously already locked, riewoldt, etc) to bring in which is why I'm looking at strengthening mids.

selwood over goddard means i get that extra week of a premium. Just not sure who will be better of the 2 long term