Trade Cotchin to Macrae

[Dasherman]

I think Cotchin will be a roller coaster as he just does work hard enough to break the the tag. Macrae has proven his form is consistent so thinking of trading him in this week for Cotchin based on form and cash.

[CubanPete]

Macrae already 420k before this week then 134 making his value go up again, almost a sideways trade by now.
will make maybe 50k if youre lucky with cotchins shower score

[rider]

Whilst this is probably an upgrade your trading someone unthought was a premo to someone who prob won't be at the end of the year. Can you upgrade him to a jobe or Joel or pendles or boyd etc

[AlexIsOnFire]

Macrae is a stepping stone to a premo, I would be looking at the likes of Pendles, Swan, Kornes, etc to bring in if you want to offload Cotch.

Cotch was tagged by the most in form tagger, I would just wear this week and keep him.

[footy25]

Keep in mind cotchin plays a Brisbane midfield who let multiple port adelaide midfielders get big scores in the next round, this is the only reason I'm gonna be keeping cotchin in for another week

[henry]

For me trading McCrae in now can only possibly end in disappointment. I can't see him doing any better than what he is now, and you've got to ask how long will this run last? Especially as Griffen gets back to full fitness and plays wholly in the middle again. I'm not convinced he will be a premo come season's end, so I'm happy to miss the mccrae train. I'm backing cotchin.

[powersuperkents]

Remember Macrae has only done well against bad teams. Once the other 12 sides are in the fixture his scoring will decrease. I was thinking Shiels-> Macrae this week (thinking Macrae was a keeper) but I remembered how the first few rounds are always deceiving (a good score in the opening rounds effects the total average compared to a good score in the middle-end of season where it barely effects the appearance of the total) and noticed that it would be a sideways if anything because both players serve the same purpose. Macrae won't average 120 for the year but I wouldn't be surprised if he went +100, however, I'd still back Cotchin over him regardless.

[Buddysbuddy]

I've had both since the start and not thinking of trading any yet just gonna rid the McRae train as long as it goes when he starts losing value then I'll trade him out

[pommyadam]

Keep in mind cotchin plays a Brisbane midfield who let multiple port adelaide midfielders get big scores in the next round, this is the only reason I'm gonna be keeping cotchin in for another week

Richmond play Brisbane next round?!
hello big tons!

[Toga]

Was considering this myself but as henry said don't think it will do anything but disappoint. The ship has sailed :(

[fidou]

Remember Macrae has only done well against bad teams. 

He wont get much against Carlton this week.

[powersuperkents]

Remember Macrae has only done well against bad teams. 

He wont get much against Carlton this week.

+1

I agree, as bad as they are this season they are one of the most restrictive fantasy sides in the comp. Boyd will probably be the only one to pass 100 and only just. I think Carlton might win the match as well but I'd still list the Bullies as favourites