Help!

Started by Maggie May, April 10, 2014, 08:16:02 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Maggie May

Okay I need some trade advice.  I had originally planned on going:

Michie to Kelly
Guthrie to Jaensch or Kolodjashnij

However I am now facing a likely donut in my forward line.  I have Wingard and Ambrose as definite outs and given it is due to injury they could be out for several weeks, and a likely non starter in Bennedy who has been named as an emergency only this week, and seems to be out of favour with the coach.  Not sure what to do. 

I think I'm still going to doe the Michie to Kelly trade, as Michie looks like he'll miss a minimum of a month, and Kelly looks too good to pass up.

For my second trade my options are:

Guthrie - Hasn't worked the way I would like, but does have good job security.  Had planned to turn him into Jaensch who is fantastic form, despite being in a losing team, or into KK who is on the bubble.  If I don't trade him this week, I may have to keep him unless his scores, and cash making ability, improves as I don't see many other good options around that mark.

Wingard - Has an ankle injury and haven't been able to get any info on the severity of the injury, so could miss a couple.  Could afford to turn him into anyone including Riewoldt , Parker, Rioli etc.  but it would be a sideways trade, and given I haven't been able to find any info, he could also be back next week, meaning it's a wasted trade.

Bennedy - Seems a little out of favour but is showing good form, and I think if given the chance, he could prove a good cash cow.  But his job security looks poor, and I would say he looks a 50/50 proposition to get the vest if he does play.  I could afford to turn him into anyone from Fasolo to J. Merrett.

Ambrose - Looked like a good prospect, but I'm sure I read he's injured and out for a few weeks so not the option I was hoping for.  I could really only afford to turn him into  Fasolo or Tom Williams as the only other options I could afford, show terrible scoring averages or haven't played yet (such as Paine).

What should I do?

RaisyDaisy

Avoiding a donut is the main priority

Bennedy to Fasolo makes the most sense

AaronKirk

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on April 10, 2014, 08:22:29 PM
Avoiding a donut is the main priority

Bennedy to Fasolo makes the most sense

Maggie May

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on April 10, 2014, 08:22:29 PM
Avoiding a donut is the main priority

Bennedy to Fasolo makes the most sense

Question if Bennedy plays as a late inclusion (apparently Maxwell only jogged laps today and the wet weather could prompt a tall for small change) is it worth keeping him and trading Ambrose for Fasolo? I can afford to do that, though not a lot of spare cash would be left.

Bully

Quote from: Maggie May on April 10, 2014, 11:14:44 PM
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on April 10, 2014, 08:22:29 PM
Avoiding a donut is the main priority

Bennedy to Fasolo makes the most sense

Question if Bennedy plays as a late inclusion (apparently Maxwell only jogged laps today and the wet weather could prompt a tall for small change) is it worth keeping him and trading Ambrose for Fasolo? I can afford to do that, though not a lot of spare cash would be left.

Save your cash & bring in Fasolo for Bennedy, Ambrose may return in 2 weeks and you stand to make some cash. You can always loophole him in the meantime. This is all contingent on the final teams but at least you have the clarity of a Friday night game.

RaisyDaisy

Just get rid of Bennedy. His JS is just too questionable