Best remaining cheap rookie mid? Templeton? Buckley? Bennell?

Started by RookieDTer, March 31, 2014, 10:32:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

RookieDTer

I want to go Wright to Wingard....

If I then trade out Viv Michie... this leaves me with $160,919.

Looking at BEs of midfielders...
I have Ellis & Polec & Tyson & Dunstan & Viv Michie
Gleeson is $50 too expensive
Cunningham is too expensive.

This leaves:
Templeton at BE -13
Buckley at -8
Bennell at 9

None of them seem to be a great choice... with Buckley being an emergency for one match only, Bennell scoring 45 and 43 and will rise the least in price.... and Templeton's 45 and 68 also best described as lacklustre....

I have Griffiths, Langford and Langdon... so I can't get GEorgiou in and afford the trade

I have Ambrose and ROwan on my Fwd bench, so can't see a better alternative....

and Currie and Derickx, so can't make $50k.

Do I need to go back to the drawing board, or can I trust one of Templeton, Buckley or Bennell???

An alternative would be -Scooter Selwood + Wingard.... but I don't see the point in that.

I have S.Mitchell, so I may need to get rid of him (helllllllo Hanley).....



-SMitchell + Hanley
-Wright + Wingard?

Money

I would take Templteton anyway, I see him having better job secruity then any of those guys and he's basically cult hero down there already, plus he'll probably be your M10 so it doesnt really matter if he scores a little below par

RookieDTer

Quote from: Money on March 31, 2014, 11:14:38 PM
I would take Templteton anyway, I see him having better job secruity then any of those guys and he's basically cult hero down there already, plus he'll probably be your M10 so it doesnt really matter if he scores a little below par
Cheers mate,

Re-reading my post, it really looks like the best out of the three.

Just toying with the idea of:
-H.Shaw (BE 100, 50 last week) +Hanley
-SMitchell (groins can be fiddly...) + Janesch (good run coming up & BE of 12)

Any thoughts whilst you are here?

mooses

buckley, did enough to hold his spot and will be hard to edge out as he shown determintion and hunger, malthouse gave him big wraps on afl confidential plus he won the rising star nomination so mick wont drop him when theres plenty other "passengers" at carlton