Dump Michie now? Trade advice

[eaglesman]

i would say absolutely do this ... michie looks a hack to me and i am hating the fact i have him ...

but most people would be like HOLD your trades

Were you expecting 100 every week from a rookie? 61 isn't terrible at all...

nope not expecting that at all ... but the player i saw looked completely out of his depth ... ill be happy to be proved wrong this week if he scores a 60 but looks like he belongs

[blackrose]

I'm thinking of next week going Matt Crouch to Georgiou and Michie to Aish of Crouch is still not getting a game and Michie underperforms again.

[ADEZ]

Definitely hold, I thought he lacked a bit of confidence to attack with the footy, done some real classy things amongst his not so classy stuff

[H1bb3i2d]

>Rookie scores 61 in a game
>It was only one game
>Will make at least $150k even if he averages 60
>60 average from an M10, not good enough?
>Logic everywhere.

If i was going to burn a trade, then heck... I'd want it to be worth some money!
Unless there's someone we've all missed that can make twice as much...

[ubeaut]

Cheers for all the replies guys. Some good points made.

I guess he just doesn't seem worth having. I know 61 is fine for a rookie and they are up and down - BUT he is mature age and did not look good at all against a very depleted fellow cellar dweller. There are a lot of Dees mids and not many points to go round.

Also I was keen on Macrae during PS but didn't have the nuts to go with him, also decided on 5 prem mids.

I'll think about it keen to hear other suggestions.

[eaglesman]

Cheers for all the replies guys. Some good points made.

I guess he just doesn't seem worth having. I know 61 is fine for a rookie and they are up and down - BUT he is mature age and did not look good at all against a very depleted fellow cellar dweller. There are a lot of Dees mids and not many points to go round.

Also I was keen on Macrae during PS but didn't have the nuts to go with him, also decided on 5 prem mids.

I'll think about it keen to hear other suggestions.

your mind will be made up when he gets dropped this week brother

[gunnerzzz]

I'm considering going Michie into Bennell and using the coin to go Thomas to Wines.... but probably gunna wait and see how they go this round. So tempting to pull the trigger on that one though!

[Fid]

Michie into Buckley could be an option in a couple of weeks

[BoredSaint]

went him up to tyson cause yelo

[jeesh]

I've got McDonald and Michie both sitting in the mids with bags packed (the amber light). At Friday 6:25 PM when big brother comes on and Sonia Kruger announces the evictee I'll be trading to Tyson. If it happens to be a double eviction you'll see a thread entitled Eminem, meaning M&M, meaning Michie and McDonald asking FF's for there opinion on which one to trade.

[jeesh]

I've got McDonald and Michie both sitting in the mids with bags packed (the amber light). At Friday 6:25 PM when big brother comes on and Sonia Kruger announces the evictee I'll be trading to Tyson. If it happens to be a double eviction you'll see a thread entitled Eminem, meaning M&M, meaning Michie and McDonald asking FF's for there opinion on which one to trade.

Scratch that last bit. If both get dropped then Michie -> Tyson makes a whole lot of sense leaving McDonald to turn into KK later on